Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
The Guardian - UK
The Guardian - UK
Sport
Barney Ronay in Munich

Bayern Munich v Barcelona: Champions League semi-final webchat

Messi
Lionel Messi scoring his 10th goal in the Champions League this season. Photograph: Emilio Morenatti/AP

Barney has signed off. Enjoy the match.

Here are a few goals for your entertainment...

Including this preposterous overhead kick:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hHR2rT1VebU

OccamsEauDeToilette asks:

Hi Barney. If Bayern do fail to progress to the finals, which seems very likely, will this season be seen as a failure bearing in mind they also lost out in the DFB cup semi-final to Dortmund recently as well?

User avatar for BarneyR Guardian staff

I think so. Ludicrous as it sounds the only real measure of success for these regional powerhouse mega-clubs is winning in Europe. Bayern have dominated theri domestic league to such a degree they have effectively depleted the merits of actually winning it. I'm not sure what can be done about this. Proper European super-league anyone? No?

Chingu asks:

Barney, do you think everyone cares too much about managers? There are so many questions on here which relate to them. Is this justified by the importance of their role or over-the-top in relation to other important factors?

User avatar for BarneyR Guardian staff

I think you're right, often we do go on about managers too much, in part because there is so little access to players and in part because of the way television has worked on football, promoting this bloke in a suit at the corner of the screen whirling around in his chalk rectangle into some incredibly vital part of the action. On the other hand at this level tactics, a game plan, the fine margins of who does what at precisely which moment do make a big difference.

Sameoldcabbage asks:

How imposing is the Allianz Arena as a stadium and is there any chance that, given an early Bayern goal, you could suddenly start using the words rabbit and headlights in the context of Barcelona defenders?

User avatar for BarneyR Guardian staff

I think it's a really great stadium. I know a lot of people disagree, and it is a bit out of the way and a bit modern. Also the atmosphere is diluted on Champions League nights because fewer of the regualrs come for reasons - i'm told - to do with ticketing and prices. But it is still a pretty stirring place. It can be very loud. and you can tell the players love playing there. The celebrations at the end of the Porto game, with Muller doing his bit with a megaphone were totally genuine. On the other hand I can;'t really see Messi being too worried about a bit of noise. His greta skill is that in every stadium, at every moment in every game he still seems to be playing the same game he started off about 20 years ago in some playground or other in Rosario.

jhopgood asks:

Why have Bayern failed to score recently and will this change tonight? I realise Robben etc are out but this would make them a one/two man band, which is unusual for a German team.

User avatar for BarneyR Guardian staff

Good point. Missing those wide men is quite a big deal. Not just because Robben, Ribery and Alaba are three of Bayern's best players. But also because having strength wide is so key to the Guardiola way. I suspect it would be closer. But Bayern would have to really turn it on to outscore this Barcelona team. I'd put it 70-30 Barca's way. But of course, we will never know. Don't forget also Barcelona have no injuries at all, which is freakishly good luck. Take Messi or Suarez out of the team and it's a lot more even.

Conlaroja asks:

Barney, remember when you said Ronaldo had no rival?

User avatar for BarneyR Guardian staff

I believe that was just before he won the Ballon D'Or a couple of weeks later by a large margin. Thereby proving he did indeed have no close rivals. Not sure what your point is

Jamety69 asks:

Hey Barney. Given that the Barça v Madrid final is still on, do you think it would be a quite a cagey bitty affair or an open spectacle where Madrid would look for revenge for losing La Liga?

User avatar for BarneyR Guardian staff

It's hard to call isn't it. I suspect there would be a lot of rolling around on the grass, people waving imaginary cards, some sneaky stuff, plenty of gesticulating. At some stage Sergio Ramos will tweak someone's nipple, then look outraged for no obvious reason. On the other hand that three-man Barca attack is just irrepressible right now. Feels a bit like it's Messi's destiny this year to do something special. I would be totally unsurprised if that happened in Berlin.

MidderP asks:

Can you see Barça running riot tonight like Madrid did in the Allianz this stage last year? Bayern’s need to get goals could be their weakness tonight, and as Pep said - Barça are now the best side in the world on the counterattack.

User avatar for BarneyR Guardian staff

It is fascinating isn't it? I'd love Pep to just say, hang it all, I'm going to stick to my attacking toe-to-toe principles and go for this, whether it's 3-5 or 1-1 makes no difference. I find i like him a lot more every time he fails, so long as he fails while still trying to be Pep, like with the slightly loopy 3-man backline, and the fialure to sit on the game at 0-0 at the Nou Camp. He's great as an idealist. We don't need another sensible manager.

OzMogwai asks:

Hi Barney (if that is your real name), realistically, what are the chances of Pep Guardiola joining Manchester City next season? And if he does, will his rivalry with Mourinho make the Premier League interesting again?

User avatar for BarneyR Guardian staff

Says someone going by the name "OzMogwai".
Like the man said, he's said 200 million times he's staying. I suppose the 2,000,001st time he could change it to "I'm going". I actually wouldn't rule anything out. Right now he's not going anywhere, but people at his level in football talk to other parties on and off, make continegency plans, keep options open. It's a precarious business. Youd be crazy not to. Oddly enough part of me doe suspect a heavy defeat tonight (a third in two years versus the really big teams) might make a difference to all this.
If he does go to City the interesting thing for me will be what he does with the team and his own ideas about how to play. Not the soap opera stuff

Homewrecker asks:

Would you consider Juventus to be underdogs going into the second leg with a 2-1 lead?

User avatar for BarneyR Guardian staff

Yes, but only because of Real Madrid's extremes of individual talent. I said before the semis I thought Madrid were the weakest of the four. I still think they are in many of the standard ways of judging a football team. Juventus are great: they know exactly ehat they're doing and they know exactly where their strengths are. With Mardid right now it's all a little clanky and unbalanced. But such is the absurdity of talent available they could still win 4-1 quite easily. A personal preference would be for a Juve win. I'd like to see a bit of genuine team-building rewarded, rather than the ability to hurl money at star names.

User avatar for BarneyR Guardian staff

Hello darkness my old friend, I've come to webchat with you again. Sorry. What I'm tyring to suggest i guess is that it's a bit silent out there. You normally get loads of questions on these. But for some reason this one looks a little slim. Which is a bit unfair. As semi-dead rubbers go, this could be a fascinating night for many reasons.

Barney will be online from 1pm BST for a chat

In the meantime, here are this week’s Champions League fixtures and some of our match previews:

Tuesday
Bayern Munich v Barcelona (0-3 first leg)

Wednesday
Real Madrid v Juventus (1-2 first leg)

Drop your questions into the comments box below. Thanks

Updated

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.