DETROIT _ Somehow a walk-off loss to a bad team without its best hitter on a day when your best pitcher was on the mound wasn't even close to the worst thing that happened to the Mariners on Sunday.
The 5-4 loss to the Tigers on Jose Iglesias' single through the drawn-in infield in the bottom of the ninth capped a disappointing series against a rebuilding/tanking Detroit team that was playing without Miguel Cabrera and playing with guys that the average fan has never heard of before.
Primed to win yet another series with lefty James Paxton getting the start, Seattle instead failed to capitalize with runners in scoring position on multiple occasions (2 for 13 ) while stranding a small village of runners (11) on the bases.
And yet, that all gets sort of overlooked. It's one loss. The Mariners suffered a far greater loss in the third inning that could impact multiple game outcomes down the road when Robinson Cano was struck on the hand by an 88-mph fastball from Tigers starter Blaine Hardy in his second at-bat. The ball rode up and in on Cano, who couldn't get out of the way. It made a sickening sound as it caught the top of Cano's hand flush against the bat. It fractured the fifth metacarpal below his pinky finger.
"It was a rough day to day," manager Scott Servais said. "It's a freak accident. I don't know how long he's going to be out or where were headed, but it certainly hurts."
Cano was in obvious and immediate agony. After a brief conversation with Servais and senior athletic trainer Rob Nodine, he was removed from the game. Cano hates coming out of games, but he knew there was no playing through it.
"I knew right away," he said. "It was kind of the same feeling I had when I broke my pinky toe in Japan."
Cano will travel with the team to Minneapolis on Sunday night and then fly to Philadelphia where he'll see a hand specialist on Tuesday to determine the extent of the fracture and the treatment for it.
"It's broken bad," he said. "I have to see what the specialist said. Maybe surgery, and we'll go from there."
But where to the Mariners go from there? Cano will be out at least a month if not longer.
"We need to have guys step up," Servais said. "We've overcome some things before. It will be an obstacle, but like I said, we'll regroup and step up and keep moving forward."
Coach-speak aside, the Mariners will have to place Cano on the 10-day disabled list and bring someone up to fill his roster spot. The possible options include Taylor Motter and Gordon Beckham. While Motter has hit some homers in the past few games for Class AAA Tacoma, he's hitting .198 on the season. Beckham came into Sunday hitting .300 with a .912 on-base plus slugging percentage. A veteran that's played over 900 big league games, the Mariners trust Beckham in that role. He also as an opt-out clause for his minor league contract on Tuesday, which he may exercise if not added to the 25-man roster.
"It's not an easy spot to fill," Servais said. "I will talk to Jerry (Dipoto) and the guys and see where we are headed. Robbie is going to be out for a little while so we have to figure it out. Our lineup is deep enough to absorb losing Robbie for a period of time."
Several Mariners fans want centerfielder Dee Gordon, who was converted to the position from second base this season, to move back to his old spot where he earned Gold Glove honors with the Marlins. Gordon has not worked out at second base at all this spring or in the season. The Mariners said they wouldn't move him around. But this situation with Cano wasn't anticipated.
"Not at this point," Servais said. "We'll have to see wait and see what's best for the ball club and how long Robbie is going to be out and make decisions from there. We'll look at other internal options at second base and go from there."
Paxton gave the Mariners a decent start. Obviously he wasn't going to be able to replicate the dominance of his previous two outings _ 16 strikeouts over seven innings vs. the A's and a no-hitter vs. the Blue Jays.
He pitched six innings, allowing three runs on six hits with no walks and four strikeouts. His streak of scoreless innings was halted at 18 when the Tigers scored two runs in the eighth inning on three singles and a fielder's choice. He admitted there was some residual fatigue from the previous two outings and also some poor pitch decisions.
"Today my fastball wasn't very good, I didn't have a lot in the tank and wasn't locating it well," he said. "We waited too long to kind of switch over and start using more offspeed stuff. I didn't feel quite as strong as I did the last two. I didn't feel like I had everything to go get today. In the future, I need to do recognizing that early and flip the switch to the breaking stuff."
Down 4-2, the Mariners rallied in the eighth inning, loading the bases against reliever Joe Jimenez. With two outs, Jean Segura hammered a hard groundball just off the glove of a diving Jose Iglesias at shortstop to score two runs and tie the game.
The Mariners lost it in the ninth on three soft groundballs. Juan Nicasio gave up an infield single Jacoby Jones. Niko Goodrum snuck a groundball past a diving Ryon Healy at first base, setting up Iglesias for the walk-off.
