Get all your news in one place.
100's of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
The Independent UK
The Independent UK
Athena Stavrou and Kate Devlin

Assisted dying bill passes the Commons by just 23 votes as Starmer backs historic change – latest

Prime minister Sir Keir Starmer is among the MPs who have backed legalising assisted dying in a historic vote following an emotional four hour debate in the Commons.

The vote has divided cabinet with health secretary Wes Streeting and deputy prime minister Angela Rayner among those who voted against the Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill at third reading.

The Bill passed with a majority of 23 on Friday, as 314 MPs voted in favour and 291 voted against.

The bill allows terminally ill adults in England and Wales with fewer than six months to live to apply for an assisted death, subject to approval by two doctors and a panel featuring a social worker, senior legal figure and psychiatrist.

It will now move to the House of Lords, where it will be scrutinised further.

MPs were given a free vote on the bill, meaning they were allowed to vote on their on beliefs rather than with a party line.

Outside parliament, protesters from both sides have rallied since this morning to make their final cases.

Supporters of the assisted dying Bill wept, jumped and hugged each other outside Parliament as the news came through that it had been passed by MPs.

Key Points

  • MPs vote for historic End of Life bill with majority of just 23
  • Full report: Vote will see assisted dying legalised in historic social change
  • Starmer backs assisted dying bill
  • MPs moved to tears during debate
  • Supporters of bill celebrate outside Parliament
  • What does the assisted dying bill mean?

Why was Dan Norris able to vote despite being asked to stay away from parliament?

16:59 , Athena Stavrou

The Independent’s Political Editor David Maddox explains:

North East Somerset MP Dan Norris, who has been suspended by Labour over rape and child abuse allegations, was able to vote in favour of assisted dying despite being asked to stay away from parliament.

He is able to do this because he is away from parliament on “a voluntary basis” and can ask a whip or another MP to vote on his behalf.

The same happened to Tory MP Andrew Rosindell when he was asked to stay away over rape allegations for around two years, with the police ultimately dropping the case.

If Mr Norris is convicted and sent to prison then he loses his right to vote and would potentially face a recall petition for a by-election in his seat.

What happens now?

16:48 , Athena Stavrou

The assisted dying bill has passed through the Commons on Friday - but it is not law yet.

It will now be passed on to the House of Lords, who will scrutinise the bill.

There is a chance that the Lords delay or make amendments to the bill.

If it passes through the Lords, the implementation of the bill has been doubled to a maximum of four years from royal assent, rather than the initially suggested two years.

If the bill was to pass later this year that would mean it might not be until 2029, potentially coinciding with the end of this Government’s parliament, that assisted dying was being offered.

A person holds a hard copy of the Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill (Stefan Rousseau/PA) (PA Archive)

How the Commons voted today:

16:31 , Athena Stavrou

(PA Wire)

Suspended MP votes by proxy

16:22 , Athena Stavrou

A Labour MP who is currently suspended has had a vote recorded on assisted dying.

Dan Norris is banned from parliament after being arrested on suspicion of rape and child sex offences.

According to Sky News, he cast a vote in favour of assisted dying by proxy.

A Labour spokesperson told the broadcaster: "Members without the party whip are allowed a proxy vote under rules agreed by the House."

Mr Norris became MP for North East Somerset and Hanham last year (Jonathan Brady/PA) (PA Archive)

Kim Leadbeater asked about bill's passage through Lords

16:11 , Athena Stavrou

Asked whether she expected any “funny games” in the second chamber, such as a delay to the Bill or a wrecking amendment, Kim Leadbeater replied: “I really hope that there are no ‘funny games’ because the process has been extremely thorough.”

She said parliamentary process “doesn’t always seem to make sense to people – it’s steeped in tradition, but it’s important that we respect parliamentary process”.

The Labour MP for Spen Valley added: “I would be upset to think that anybody was playing games with such an important and such an emotional issue.”

Kim Leadbeater has been the MP behind the assisted dying bill (Jonathan Brady/PA) (PA Wire)

Speaking to journalists about the Bill’s future, and whether it will become law in this session, Ms Leadbeater said: “We don’t know when the session will end.”

She added: “The Government’s got a lot of bills to get through, so that will take some time, so I’m not imagining that’s going to be imminently, but it could be before the end of the year.”

Ms Leadbeater said she expected a “very strong debate going forward” in the Lords.

'Key concerns' remain unresolved: Royal College of Psychiatrists

16:01 , Athena Stavrou

Many “key concerns” surrounding the assisted dying Bill remain unresolved after it was passed to the House of Lords, the Royal College of Psychiatrists said.

The organisation’s president Dr Lade Smith CBE said: “We are particularly concerned that the Bill does not currently require a holistic assessment of unmet need.

“Does a person have a mental disorder that is contributing to their wish to die? Do they feel like a burden? Are they lonely? Do they have access to the care they need?

“We also have concerns relating to risk factors for suicide, the Mental Capacity Act, and workforce shortages.

“We remain focused on sharing our expert clinical insight to ensure the Bill has strong safeguards for those who are vulnerable, especially people with mental illness, intellectual disability and autistic people, to ensure the Bill is in line with the role and core duties of psychiatrists and other doctors, should it become law.”

Dame Esther Rantzen welcomes assisted dying vote

15:42 , Holly Evans

In an interview with ITV News she said: “It’s really important it becomes law so dying people in the future will have confidence knowing they can ask for a quick pain free death.

"It won’t come in my lifetime, I won’t live long enough but I am so relieved it will help future generations to look forward to a good death. I am astonished I have lived to see the moment.

"Months ago before the PM was elected he said that he would do his best to make sure I witnessed debate. I didn’t think it was possible, it’s happened, I’m astonished."

Dame Esther Rantzen has been an outspoken campaigner on the assisted dying Bill (Esther Rantzen/PA) (PA Media)

Assisted dying: How your MP voted

15:36 , Holly Evans

Assisted dying: How your MP voted – the full list

Marie Curie calls for palliative care available to be reviewed

15:33 , Holly Evans

Marie Curie has called for end-of-life care to be urgently reviewed to look at gaps in the system.

The organisation’s chief executive, Matthew Reed, said: “If assisted dying is legalised, it is more crucial than ever that our governments across the UK ensure that there is palliative care available for anyone who needs it.

“It is impossible to imagine that this could be achieved without an assessment of the quality and distribution of palliative care services currently available.

“While we welcome that the assisted dying bill has been amended to require such an assessment, this will not on its own make the improvements needed to guarantee everyone is able to access the palliative care they need.”

He said Marie Curie will keep making the case to the Government for a palliative care strategy for England with “a sustainable funding settlement” and to ask the incoming Welsh Government to “transform palliative and end-of-life care” to ensure equal access to good care.

He added: “Marie Curie remains neutral on the question of whether assisted dying should be legalised, and whether the law changes in England and Wales or not, it is vital that governments across the UK are held to account to ensure plans are in place to fix end-of-life care for good.”

Angela Rayner and Wes Streeting voted against the Terminally Ill Adults Bill

15:16 , Holly Evans

Health Secretary Wes Streeting and Deputy Prime Minister Angela Rayner voted against the Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill at third reading.

According to the Commons division list, they were joined in the “no” lobby by Cabinet colleagues: Justice Secretary Shabana Mahmood, Education Secretary Bridget Phillipson, Business Secretary Jonathan Reynolds, Cabinet Office minister Nick Thomas-Symonds and chief secretary to the Treasury Darren Jones.

Voting in favour were: Transport Secretary Heidi Alexander, Northern Ireland Secretary Hilary Benn, chief whip Alan Campbell, Home Secretary Yvette Cooper, Work and Pensions Secretary Liz Kendall, Cabinet Office minister Pat McFadden, Energy Secretary Ed Miliband, Scotland Secretary Ian Murray, Commons Leader Lucy Powell, Environment Secretary Steve Reed, Chancellor Rachel Reeves and Wales Secretary Jo Stevens.

Care minister Stephen Kinnock, who spoke at the end of Friday’s debate, voted in favour of the Bill.

Kim Leadbeater in tears as MPs vote in favour of assisted dying bill

15:12 , Holly Evans

Kim Leadbeater in tears as MPs vote in favour of assisted dying bill

Watch: MPs vote in favour of assisted dying bill

15:06 , Holly Evans

Bill 'faces an uphill battle' to get through the House of Lords

15:03 , Holly Evans

Opposition campaigners Right To Life UK said the Bill “still faces an uphill battle” to get through the House of Lords.

Spokeswoman Catherine Robinson said: “Although the Bill passed the Commons today, momentum remains with its opponents, with support consistently falling every time MPs have considered it.

“The Bill leaves the Commons lacking a majority, with fewer than half of all MPs voting for it at its final stage.

“The Bill still faces an uphill battle to reach Royal Assent. We will be fighting it at every stage in the House of Lords.”

Bill fails to protect 'vulnerable and disabled people'

14:58 , Holly Evans

The Bill remains “deeply flawed and dangerous”, opposition campaigners said after the vote.

Gordon Macdonald, chief executive of Care Not Killing said: “This is a deeply flawed and dangerous Bill that since November has been made considerably worse with important safeguards watered down or scrapped.”

He added: “The current Bill fails to protect vulnerable and disabled people from coercion.”

Nuns opposing the assisted dying Bill demonstrate at Parliament Square (Lucy North/PA Wire)

Starmer backs assisted dying bill

14:54 , Holly Evans

Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer has backed the Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill at third reading, the Commons division list shows.

It also shows Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch cast her vote in the “no” lobby, voting against plans to roll out assisted dying in the UK.

Campaign groups welcome result

14:47 , Athena Stavrou

Campaign groups in favour of assisted dying have welcomed today’s vote in the Commons.

Andrew Copson, Chief Executive of Humanists UK, said: “MPs have finally recognised the fact that assisted dying is already happening in this country.

“People are travelling to Switzerland if they have the money and mobility to do so. Others are dying in traumatic circumstances by suicide.

“Many more are suffering greatly, even while receiving the best possible care.

“Today, we are a significant step closer to ending that unnecessary and cruel suffering and MPs should be commended for taking this step.”

Full report: Vote will see assisted dying legalised in historic social change

14:42 , Athena Stavrou

Assisted dying is one step closer to becoming law after a historic vote in the House of Commons, paving the way for one of the biggest changes to social policy since abortion was legalised in 1967.

Following an emotional debate, the Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill was passed by 314 to 291 with a majority of just 23, in a major victory for its sponsor Kim Leadbeater.

The Independent’s Political Editor David Maddox reports:

Assisted dying set to be legalised as MPs back Kim Leadbeater’s bill in historic vote

'This means I can die holding my children's hands'

14:41 , Athena Stavrou

Supporters of the Bill were clearly emotional and happy outside Parliament as the news broke it had been passed.

Jenny Carruthers, 57, from Bath, had retired from the NHS due to ill-health.

She said she felt emotional and relieved.

Ms Carruthers wiped tears from her eyes and hugged friends and fellow campaigners.

She said: “This means that I can die holding my children’s hands.”

(AFP via Getty Images)

Supporters of bill celebrate outside Parliament

14:37 , Athena Stavrou

Supporters of the assisted dying Bill wept, jumped and hugged each other outside Parliament as the news came through that it had been passed by MPs.

The crowd of around 100 people in Parliament Square, Westminster, erupted into cheers on Friday afternoon as the news was livestreamed over a speaker by campaigners from Dignity In Dying.

One supporter said: “Yes, dad” and others patted each other on the shoulder.

“This is for all the people who couldn’t be here today. This vote sends a clear message. Parliament stands with the public and change is coming,” said Sarah Wootton, chief executive of Dignity in Dying.

(Lucy North/PA Wire)

MPs vote for historic End of Life bill with majority of just 23

14:31 , Athena Stavrou

MPs have voted in favour of the assisted dying bill after an emotional four hour debate moved MPs to tears in the Commons.

314 MPs voted in favour of the Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill on Friday afternoon.

291 voted against the legislation, meaning the bill passed with a majority of 23.

House divided to vote

14:15 , Athena Stavrou

MPs have now cleared the lobby to vote on the assisted dying bill.

We will bring you the result as soon as it is called.

Starmer arrived to vote

14:13 , Athena Stavrou

The prime minister has arrived at parliament in time to vote on the assisted dying bill.

There was speculation earlier that Sir Keir Starmer would not vote as he was dealing with conflict in the Middle East.

But he is now sat on the frontbench, minutes before a vote is set to be called.

(PA Wire)
14:08 , Athena Stavrou

(Yui Mok/PA Wire)
(Lucy North/PA Wire)
(Yui Mok/PA Wire)

Watch: MPs in tears during emotional debate

13:58 , Athena Stavrou

Families outside parliament tell stories of loved-ones

13:52 , Athena Stavrou

Teachers Catie and Becky Fenner attended a gathering of Dignity in Dying campaigners in Parliament Square ahead of the vote.

Their mother, who had motor neurone disease, flew to Dignitas in Switzerland to end her life.

The sisters said worrying about the legal implications of this meant they did not get to properly say goodbye and grieve.

Catie, 37, from Oxfordshire, said: “We had to stay behind because mum was insistent she wanted to protect us.

“We didn’t have the goodbye we wanted.

“It cost £15,000. Luckily, we could afford that but many people cannot.

“We were left quite traumatised by the whole experience – not only seeing a parent go through a really horrible disease but then the secrecy of the planning. We couldn’t tell anyone.

“We have had grief counselling. We don’t want any other family to go through what we went through.

“We want families to be able to say goodbye in this country without the fear of prosecution.”

(Lucy North/PA Wire)

MPs moved to tears by personal stories

13:32 , Athena Stavrou

Today’s debate and vote on the assisted dying bill is clearly a personal issue for many in and out of the Commons.

In the chamber, MPs have brought personal and emotional stories to the debate - bringing some of their colleagues to tears.

Maureen Burked, Labour MP for Glasgow North East, shared an emotional story about her brother, who was diagnosed with advanced pancreatic cancer.

(Parliament TV)

She described his deteriorating condition, which eventually left him unable to speak due to the strength of his painkillers.

“One of the last times when he still was able to speak, he called out to me from his bed and told me if there was a pill that he could take to end his life, he would very much like to take that," she said.

As she said she was “doing right by her brother” by speaking up in favour of the bill, her colleagues behind her were visibly moved to tears.

An hour to go until MPs have to vote

13:25 , Athena Stavrou

MPs have been debating the assisted dying bill since this morning, and now have just an hour left if they choose to vote today.

The Commons only give until 2:30pm for private members bills to be debated on Friday, which means MPs have to vote before then.

Poll of the day: Do you support the assisted dying bill?

13:20 , Athena Stavrou

The assisted dying bill, facing a knife-edge vote after key safeguards were dropped, has reignited a deeply divisive debate over dignity, safety, and the limits of end-of-life choice.

With so much at stake and such deeply personal questions at the heart of this debate, we want to hear from you: do you support the assisted dying bill?

Vote in our poll in the story below and let us know your thoughts in the comments:

Poll: Do you support the assisted dying bill?

Watch: James Cleverly’s tells MPs of ‘painful’ death of best friend in assisted dying bill debate

13:15 , Athena Stavrou

Care Not Killing CEO: Starmer should take responsibility for bill

13:08 , Athena Stavrou

The chief executive of Care Not Killing has called for MPs to reject the bill as he said Sir Keir Starmer should have taken responsibility for it.

Speaking outside Parliament, Dr Gordon Macdonald said: “There are still lots of problems with this bill, and MPs should reject it today.

“As this is a private members’ bill, the MP in charge of the bill was able to choose who she wanted in the committee, choose who she wanted to give evidence and decide which amendments would be accepted and which wouldn’t, so I believe the whole process is completely flawed and I believe the Government needs to hold responsibility for this.

“Keir Starmer should have taken responsibility for this.”

(AP)

MPs explain why they've switched positions

12:58 , Athena Stavrou

A Conservative backbencher indicated he had changed his voting position on the assisted dying Bill since it was first introduced.

Mike Wood, the MP for Kingswinford and South Staffordshire, told the Commons: “I didn’t vote at second reading in November.

“The member for Spen Valley (Kim Leadbeater) in her opening speech this morning said that we could choose to vote with our head or with our heart.

“I am afraid it is that tension, that conflict, that I have been grappling with over the last few months.”

He said his “sympathy of the principle of assisted dying was as strong as it ever was”, but later added he would be “voting against this afternoon” because he did not believe the Bill offered enough safeguards.

Downing Street declines to comment on whether Starmer will vote

12:48 , Athena Stavrou

Downing Street declined to say whether Sir Keir Starmer will attend the Commons debate on the assisted dying Bill.

A Number 10 spokesman said: “I’m not going to get ahead of proceedings in the House or speculate on the prime minister’s movements… the prime minister is working in Number 10, but as I say I’m not going to speculate on the PM’s movements today.”

Sir Keir Starmer has urged all sides to pursue a diplomatic solution (Jordan Pettitt/PA) (PA Wire)

For context:

Earlier, reports suggested Sir Keir, who supports the bill, may not attend the Commons.

But The Times reported that Starmer could miss the vote as he deals with the growing conflict between Iran and Israel.

Watch: Campaigners gather outside parliament before crunch vote

12:40 , Athena Stavrou

Compassion 'at core' of bill, MP says

12:34 , Athena Stavrou

Labour MP Rachel Hopkins has urged her colleagues to support the assisted dying bill in the Commons.

Ms Hopkins, who co-sponsored the bill, said dying people are “at the heart” of the legislation, which she says has “compassion at its core”.

Anorexia 'loophole' still not closed, MP says

12:30 , Athena Stavrou

An MP has warned that, despite an earlier amendment, a “loophole” allowing anorexia patients to access assisted dying is still not closed.

Labour MP Naz Shah told the Commons that she had originally supported the assisted dying bill “in principle”, she did not believe the proposed legislation was safe.

Referring to her amendment 14 to prevent a patient meeting the requirements for an assisted death “solely as a result of voluntarily stopping eating or drinking”, which MPs backed earlier on Friday, and a further amendment 38 which was not added to the Bill, Ms Shah told the Commons: “This is not the anorexia loophole that has been closed – that was another amendment.

(Parliament TV)

“When people stop voluntarily eating and drinking, that is not what happens to people with anorexia. People with anorexia stop eating and drinking because they have a psychiatric illness. These are two categorically different issues.

“So I must make it clear, absolutely clear, even though amendment 14 has passed today, this amendment does not address concerns about anorexia or close that loophole.”

Protesters continue to gather outside parliament

12:22 , Athena Stavrou

In Parliament Square, campaigners opposing the Bill, wearing white T-shirts, appeared to outnumber those for the Bill, wearing pink T-shirts.

Campaigners against the Bill chanted “We are not dead yet” and “Kill the Bill, not the ill”.

A display was erected with a gravestone reading “R.I.P: The Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill. Bury it deep”, and behind were two mounds apparently meant to resemble graves.

One campaigner against the Bill could be seen being spoken to by police after shouting at an opposing activist.

(Yui Mok/PA Wire)

Lib Dem MP reads out traumatic letter from a constituent

12:15 , Athena Stavrou

The Independent’s Political Editor David Maddox reports:

Lib Dem MP Josh Babarinde, a supporter of the Bill has read out a letter from a constituent describing the traumatic end of their partner.

The slow painful death could have been avoided, he said if there had been assisted dying legislation in place.

The strategy of rehearsing terrible cases has been fall back argument for many supporters of the Bill.

However, on interventions Mr Babarinde was unwilling to deal with issues of coercion and implied that he did not agree with the concept of “self coercion”.The dividing lines in the chamber are clear.

(BBC News)

Watch: Kim Leadbeater tells MPs failure to back assisted dying is ‘a vote for the status quo’

12:10 , Athena Stavrou

Doctor explains why he changed his mind on bill

11:57 , Athena Stavrou

Labour MP Peter Prinsley, a supporter of the bill, has explained that as a young doctor he would have opposed the bill but now “as an old doctor” supports it.

He emphasised that dignity in life should also be balanced by dignity in death.

Dr Prinsley is the doctor in the chamber to speak on the bill, he will not be the last with divisions on both sides of the medical profession.

But he said his experience of patients suffering meant that he believes assisted dying is necessary.

MPs bringing personal stories to debate

11:50 , Athena Stavrou

Today’s debate and vote on the assisted dying bill is clearly a personal issue for many in and out of the Commons.

In the chamber, MPs have brought personal and emotional stories to the debate.

Conservative former minister Sir James Cleverly said moments with his “dear friend” might have been “lost” if assisted dying was an option at the time of his death.

This came in response to an intervention from Dame Siobhain McDonagh, who spoke of her late sister Baroness Margret McDonagh.

(House of Commons/UK Parliament/PA Wire)

The Labour MP spoke about taking her sister to hospital three weeks before her death with a blood infection, and being told she shouldn’t go into intensive care because she had a brain tumour and was going to die.

Lib Dem MP Josh Babarinde, a supporter of the Bill has read out a letter from a constituent describing the traumatic end of their partner.

The slow painful death could have been avoided, he said if there had been assisted dying legislation in place.

Prue Leith among campaigners 'quietly confident' bill will pass

11:41 , Athena Stavrou

Dame Prue Leith, who has spoken out frequently in favour of a change in the law, told campaigners that she was “quietly confident” about the outcome of the vote.

The cook and television presenter said supporters outside Parliament were “wonderful” and spoke of the “uphill battle” of the campaign.

She said: “This campaign has been going on for years and has been a hard, uphill battle.

“I find it so moving to see all the photographs of people you’ve lost or who are dying of cancer as we speak.

“It is utterly disgraceful that in a civilised world, we should be allowing this.

Dame Prue Leith joins activists from Dignity in Dying in support of the assisted dying Bill in Parliament Square (PA)

“It strikes me over and over again that I put down all my life my dogs, cats, my horse, all because I know they could not bear their lives any longer, but we aren’t allowed to as human beings – isn’t that ridiculous?

“Today, I hope we are going to win. I try to be quietly confident. But whether we win or lose, you have done a fantastic job, and I hope we’re not going to have to ask you to do it again.”

James Cleverly says hopes peers will improve assisted dying legislation ‘should set off alarm bells’

11:29 , Athena Stavrou

The Independent’s Whitehall Editor Kate Devlin reports:

Former Tory cabinet minister James Cleverly has said he will not vote for the bill, warning it is not a good enough piece of legislation to pass.

He told other MPs that, like all of them, he wanted to back moves to “alleviate suffering.”

But he said that both proponents and opponents of the current bill hope that it will be improved as it makes its way through the House of Lords “and that should set off alarm bells”.

(Parliament TV)

Diane Abbott makes the socialist case against assisted dying

11:27 , Athena Stavrou

The Independent’s Political Editor David Maddox reports:

The veteran Labour MP Diane Abbott has been a strong opponent from the outset of assisted dying.

She has argued that for the poorest the Bill leaves little choice but to accept assisted dying.

But interestingly she raises the problem of a privatised for profit service, which the Bill specifically allows.

She said: “This bill will allow private for profit contractors to run a service for profit.”

She noted that an amendment to address this issue was rejected.

(PA)

Protesters face off outside parliament

11:22 , Athena Stavrou

Campaigners have gathered outside Parliament to make last-ditch appeals for and against assisted dying as MPs prepare for a crucial vote.

Supporters and opponents of a change in the law gathered at Westminster early on Friday, holding placards saying “Let us choose” and “Don’t make doctors killers”.

(Yui Mok/PA Wire)
Dame Prue Leith joins activists from Dignity in Dying in support of the assisted dying Bill in Parliament Square (Yui Mok/PA Wire)
Dame Esther Rantzen's daughter Rebecca Wilcox with campaigner and cancer sufferer Sophie Blake (back to camera) supporting the Dignity in Dying protest in favour of the assisted dying Bill, in Parliament Square, (Yui Mok/PA Wire)
(Lucy North/PA Wire)

Analysis: Contrast between Kim Leadbeater at second reading and Kim Leadbeater at third reading

11:15 , Athena Stavrou

The Independent’s Political Editor David Maddox reports:

Kim Leadbeater has been going through the long haul with her assisted dying legislation and today’s speech underlines the toll it has taken on her.

The Labour MP in her second reading speech in December was conciliatory and tried to reach out to those who opposed her legislation emphasising that both perspectives came from a point of compassion.

But this third reading speech has been bad tempered and dismissive of concerns raised with some quite harsh language about the consequences of rejecting her bill.

She ended up refusing interventions and is clearly fed up with the onslaught of criticism she has received over the last few months.

It was a speech for the converted, it may not be one for those still yet to make up their minds.

James Cleverly expressing concern over bill

11:06 , Athena Stavrou

James Cleverly is now speaking in the Commons expressing concern over Kim Leadbeater’s bill.

The former Home secretary is arguing for the opposition. He has argued the “gold standard” of scrutiny of the bill that was promised has not been delivered.

He also rejected Leadbeater’s assertion that it is “now or never” on assisted dying.

(Parliament TV)

Kim Leadbeater tells MPs failure to back assisted dying is ‘a vote for the status quo’

10:59 , Athena Stavrou

The Independent’s Whitehall Editor Kate Devlin reports:

The backbench MP who proposed the assisted dying bill has spoken in the debate in the Commons, telling the chamber that as MPs “discussing deaths is something we shy away from and yet it will come to us all”.

She said her legislation was something that “Parliament could be proud of”.

Many MPs disagree and plan to oppose it in a crunch vote later, but she told them “not supporting the vote today is not a neutral act - it is a vote for the status quo”.

Bill sponsor Kim Leadbeater (Jonathan Brady/PA) (PA Wire)

Watch live: MPs cast final vote for assisted dying bill

10:56 , Athena Stavrou

Watch live as MPs debate and vote on the controversial assisted dying bill for the terminally ill in the House of Commons on Friday:

Analysis | Are the anti-assisted dying MPs holding back

10:53 , Athena Stavrou

The Independent’s Political Editor David Maddox reports:

The early votes look pretty good for Kim Leadbeater because she is beating unwanted safeguards very easily but something is going on with the voting.

Almost all the pro-assisted dying MPs are voting on the amendments but many of the antis are apparently holding back.

In particular many Conservatives who oppose the Bill have not voted so far this morning.It could be that there is a sophisticated strategy at play with those opposed hoping to make Ms Leadbeater look unreasonable by not taking on some of the safeguards.

However, they have not wanted votes on extra safeguards to pass because it means more of the undecideds would be willing to support the Bill on the final third reading vote.

If all the antis come back at around 2.30pm the result could be very close with a narrow victory for Ms Leadbeater still predicted.

Leadbeater facing questions in the Commons

10:52 , Athena Stavrou

Kim Leadbeater has begun the third reading of her bill, and has already faced a number of questions from other MPs.

Members have asked the Labour MP about objections to the bill voiced by palliative care workers and others.

Third reading begins

10:45 , Athena Stavrou

All of the amendments have now been voted on and the third reading of the bill has begun.

Before asking Kim Leadbeater to begin the reading, the speaker urged MPs to keep their comments short as a huge amount of members wish to speak.

Ms Leadbeater, who is behind the bill, began her speech by saying: “It has been a long journey to get here and I do not underestimate the significance of this day.”

(Parliament TV)

Ban on advertising assisted dying

10:42 , Athena Stavrou

A ban on advertising assisted dying would be extended to all of the UK, should the Bill pass, MPs have agreed.

They also voted for the UK-wide extension of regulations about approved substances intended to be used to help terminally ill patients to die.

They also approved an opt-out for medical professionals being extended to Scotland.

MPs voted 275 in favour, 209 against, majority 66.

More amendments being voted on than expected

10:38 , Athena Stavrou

As we’ve been reporting, MPs are voting on a number of amendments to the bill before the third reading and final debate begins.

We were expecting four votes - with many others thought to be nodded through without a vote.

But some of these, such as amendment 77, have been unexpectedly voted on after objections in the chamber.

Amendment 77 expands the powers of the bill to all of the UK rather than just England and Wales.

It was passed by 66 votes.

Report on palliative care has to be deliered within a year

10:32 , Athena Stavrou

Ministers will have a year to report on how assisted dying could affect palliative care, if the Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill passes.

MPs called “aye” to approve Liberal Democrat MP Munira Wilson’s amendment 21.

Ministers would have to consider the state of health services for patients near the end of their lives, covering pain and symptom management, psychological support and access to information.

Amendment on NHS act rejected

10:25 , Athena Stavrou

MPs have agreed that ministers should get powers to update the National Health Service Act 2006 as part of the Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill, to include voluntary assisted dying services as part of the NHS’s purposes.

Amid fears the Bill could become “the Trojan horse that breaks the NHS”, aired last Friday, Labour MP Dame Siobhain McDonagh pushed her amendment 12 to a vote, which would have blocked ministers from broadening the NHS’s purposes without a fresh bill.

But MPs rejected Dame Siobhain’s proposal 269 votes to 223, majority 46.

(PA Wire)

437 MPs (out of 650) took part in the first assisted dying vote

10:20 , Athena Stavrou

The Independent’s Whitehall Editor Kate Devlin reports:

A total of 473 MPs took part in the first vote on assisted dying - on an attempt to amend the bill. The number is more than 200 short of the 650 MPs who make up the House of Commons.

Numbers are expected to grow over the day, however.

Some MPs are on their way from their constituencies, including NI MP Sorcha Eastwood, who had Covid earlier this week. And more are expected to join for the crunch vote about 2.30pm.

But if the result is narrow, it will be interesting to see how many MPs are in the chamber.

(Parliament TV)

MPs reject amendment to disapply presumption of mental capacity

10:06 , Athena Stavrou

A proposal to disapply the presumption that a person has capacity unless the opposite is established in cases of assisted dying requests, has been rejected by MPs.

The Commons voted 213 to 266, majority 53 to reject amendment 24, which was tabled by Labour MP Daniel Francis (Bexleyheath and Crayford).

The house has now divided once again to vote on amendment 12, which would prevent section 1 of the National Health Service Act 2006, which sets out the purposes of the NHS, from being amended by regulations.

MPs vote on series of amendments to bill

09:59 , Athena Stavrou

MPs have been voting on a number of amendments to the assisted dying bill ahead of its third reading today.

MPs have voted to reject an amendment which would have prevented a person who is substantially motivated by feeling they are a burden, from qualifying for assisted dying.

Conservative MP Rebecca Paul’s new clause 16 stated that a wish to end one’s own life should not be substantially motivated by factors such as a mental disorder, disability or suicidal ideation.

(Parliament TV)

They then supported a safeguard which would prevent a person meeting the requirements for an assisted death “solely as a result of voluntarily stopping eating or drinking”.

Kim Leadbeater said this, combined with existing safeguards in the Bill, would rule out people with anorexia falling into its scope.

Not clear if Starmer will vote today - reports

09:55 , Athena Stavrou

Reports have suggested that Sir Keir Starmer may not vote on today’s landmark assisted dying bill.

The prime minister has previously spoken in support of the bill, introduced by Labour MP Kim Leadbeater.

But The Times reported that Starmer could miss the vote as he deals with the growing conflict between Iran and Israel.

(PA Wire)

MPs vote on an amendment to explicitly rule out assisted dying for those motivated by other factors

09:48 , Athena Stavrou

The Independent’s Whitehall Editor Kate Devlin reports:

MPs are currently voting on new clause 16, which has been tabled by the Conservative MP Rebecca Paul.

This amendment proposes that a person would not be eligible for assisted dying if their wish to end their life was substantially motivated by factors such as not wanting to be a burden, a mental disorder, a disability, financial considerations, a lack of access to care, or suicidal ideation.

(Parliament TV)

MPs voting on amendments ahead of third reading

09:47 , Athena Stavrou

As we’ve been reporting, MPs have begun today’s session by voting on a series of amendments to the bill.

We are expecting around four of these to be voted on before the third reading of the bill goes ahead.

The amendments include things such as proposing a person would not be eligible for assisted dying if they were motivated by factors such as not wanting to be a burden.

Moment of truth for the assisted dying bill: all you need to know

09:42 , Athena Stavrou

Kim Leadbeater, the Labour MP who came top in the private members’ bill ballot last year, and was therefore given a chance of getting her own law onto the statute book, is “confident” that her Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill will complete its Commons stages on Friday.

After much debate, the bill to legalise suicide for terminally ill adults faces its critical House of Commons vote on Friday. John Rentoul looks at what might happen:

Assisted dying bill explained: All you need to know as MPs vote on landmark bill

Commons debate to begin shortly

09:34 , Athena Stavrou

The third reading of the assisted dying bill is set to begin shortly in the Commons.

The session will begin with a vote on a few amendments - it is unclear what these will be yet.

The third reading will then begin and then the debate will start.

A vote is expected later in the afternoon.

We will bring you the latest updates from the Commons here.

(Copyright 2025 The Associated Press. All rights reserved)

Analysis | Is a private members’ bill the wrong way to try to bring in assisted dying?

09:23 , Athena Stavrou

The Independent’s Whitehall Editor Kate Devlin reports:

MPs are voting today on a historic change in the law that could alter the face of British society.

Yet, many might be surprised to find the assisted dying bill is not a government bill.

It’s what is known as a private members bill, and has been brought by a backbench MP.

There has been tacit support for allowing the bill to go ahead - including giving Labour MPs a free vote on the issue, seen as one of conscience.

But changes of this magnitude have often been done with the work of government behind them - or even a Royal Commission.

The great exception, of course, was abortion in 1967.

But campaigners argue that was to legislate - and make safer - something that was already happening. And arguably ushered in less sweeping change.

Pictured: Campaigners supporting and opposing the assisted dying bill gather outside parliament

09:12 , Athena Stavrou

(Lucy North/PA Wire)
(Lucy North/PA Wire)
(Lucy North/PA Wire)

Expected in the Commons today:

09:06 , Athena Stavrou

The debate on the assisted dying bill will begin in the Commons at 9:30am.

A few amendments will be voted on first - and then the third reading of the bill will begin.

The main debate will take place, with support and opposition expected from both sides of the chamber.

The vote is expected to happen by 2:30pm. But there is a possibility MPs run out of time to vote and the fate of the bill will be pushed back to another day.

MPs will gather in the Commons for further debate on the assisted dying Bill (Anthony Devlin/PA) (PA Archive)

What will happen if the bill passes through the Commons today?

08:58 , Athena Stavrou

The Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill will be debated and voted on by MPs today.

But if a majority votes in favour - it will not be law yet.

It will then be passed on to the House of Lords, who will scrutinise the bill.

There is a chance that the Lords delay or make amendments to the bill.

Lord Ranger was ennobled in 2019 in Theresa May’s resignation honours list (PA) (PA Archive)

If it passes through the Lords, the implementation of the bill has been doubled to a maximum of four years from royal assent, rather than the initially suggested two years.

If the bill was to pass later this year that would mean it might not be until 2029, potentially coinciding with the end of this Government’s parliament, that assisted dying was being offered.

73% of UK public support bill, polling suggests

08:46 , Athena Stavrou

A YouGov poll of 2,003 adults in Great Britain, surveyed last month and published on Thursday, suggested public support for the Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill remains high at 73 per cent – unchanged from November.

The proportion of people who feel assisted dying should be legal in principle has risen slightly, to 75 per cent from 73 per cent in November.

(Copyright 2025 The Associated Press. All rights reserved)

Analysis | Assisted dying bill: Why this momentous vote remains so uncertain

08:38 , Athena Stavrou

The third reading and final Commons vote on Kim Leadbeater’s Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill on Friday marks a truly historic moment for parliament.

Kim Leadbeater’s bill passed with a majority of 55 at the second reading, but David Maddox explains why there is still a chance it could be voted down.

Read the analysis here:

Why the landmark assisted dying vote remains so uncertain - up to the final minute

Labour MPs withdraw support from 'drastically weakened' bill

08:23 , Athena Stavrou

Four Labour MPs have withdrawn their support from the assisted dying bill on the eve of a crunch vote.

Labour’s Paul Foster, Jonathan Hinder, Markus Campbell-Savours and Kanishka Narayan wrote to fellow MPs to voice concerns about the safety of the proposed legislation.

They branded it “drastically weakened”, citing the scrapping of the High Court Judge safeguard as a key reason.

Since its initial vote in Parliament, the Bill has had significant changes made. These include the replacement of a High Court safeguard with an expert panel.

Culture Secretary: I'm still a supporter of this bill

08:14 , Athena Stavrou

Lisa Nandy has said she hopes to see the assisted dying Bill pass through the Commons on Friday.

The Culture Secretary said she is still a supporter of the Bill, despite some of her Labour colleagues announcing that they would now be voting against after previously offering support.

“I’m still a supporter of this Bill. I’ve had a longstanding personal commitment to change the law on assisted dying with appropriate safeguards. And I think there has been a very considered and respectful debate over the last few months on all sides,” Ms Nandy told Sky News.

The Cabinet minister said she respected “the views of colleagues who take a different view”, adding: “I hope the Bill succeeds today. If it does pass the House of Commons stages, of course it will go on to the House of Lords, where there will be more debate and there may be more changes.

Culture Secretary Lisa Nandy. (Gareth Fuller/PA) (PA Wire)

Landmark bill hangs in balance ahead of crucial MP vote

08:02 , Athena Stavrou

MPs are set to take part in a landmark vote on assisted dying on Friday.

The third and final reading of the Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill in the Commons will go ahead at 9:30am.

This will be followed by a debate and likely a vote in the afternoon.

A person holds a hard copy of the Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill (Stefan Rousseau/PA) (PA Archive)

How have key figures said they'll vote?

05:02 , Athena Stavrou

Prime minister Sir Keir Starmer has indicated he will continue to back the Bill, as he did last year, saying earlier this week that his “position is long-standing and well-known” on assisted dying.

Health Secretary Wes Streeting, while describing Ms Leadbeater’s work on the proposed legislation as “extremely helpful”, confirmed in April that he still intended to vote against it.

Tory leader Kemi Badenoch has called the proposed legislation a “bad bill” that will not deliver and urged Conservative MPs to follow suit.

(via REUTERS)

Back my assisted dying bill or face another decade of death without dignity, Kim Leadbeater warns MPs

02:00 , Athena Stavrou

Kim Leadbeater has made a last-minute plea to MPs to support her assisted dying bill, warning that if it is rejected on Friday, terminally ill adults could face a ten-year wait before the issue is debated again.

Back my assisted dying bill or face decade of death without dignity, Leadbeater warns

What does the bill mean?

01:02 , Athena Stavrou

The Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill would allow terminally ill adults in England and Wales, with fewer than six months to live, to apply for an assisted death.

It would be subject to approval by two doctors and a panel featuring a social worker, senior legal figure and psychiatrist.

(EPA)

Landmark bill hangs in balance ahead of crucial MPs vote

Thursday 19 June 2025 23:59 , Athena Stavrou

MPs are set to take part in a landmark vote on assisted dying on Friday.

The third and final reading of the Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill in the Commons will go ahead at 9:30am.

This will be followed by a debate and likely a vote in the afternoon.

A person holds a hard copy of the Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill (Stefan Rousseau/PA) (PA Archive)
Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100's of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.