100s of titles, one news app for just $10 a month.
Dive Deeper:
‘Had better days’: Alan Tudge’s single exchange with education department since standing down
Confusion has surrounded post of education minister since PM insisted Tudge was still in cabinet, despite standing aside
What the hell is going on with Alan Tudge?
The on-again/off-again education minister is a man of mystery — and it looks like the voting public will just have…
Alan Tudge emerges on WeChat to respond to questions about ‘toxic gender ideology’
Coalition MP, who has been absent from the campaign, stars in three-minute video telling voters to ‘think carefully who you…
Leaders' debate: Albanese wins final debate, Morrison confirms Tudge will re-enter cabinet if re-elected
Anthony Albanese wins the third leaders' debate which saw he and Scott Morrison cover well-trodden issues, but also the Prime…
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
A failure as shameful as robodebt leaves questions only a royal commission can examine
Without an understanding of how this unlawful scheme occurred, what’s to stop something similar happening again?
Female voters are queueing up to belt Scott Morrison, and it could get very ugly
The prime minister is on the nose with women, and it’s gone from bad to worse since the Brittany Higgins…
Get all your news in one place
Latest National news:
Homes of the Hunter: As comfortable as country can get
Jim Kellar visits a property so stunning in its attention to detail that it's inspirational.
Read news from The Economist, FT, Bloomberg and more, with one subscription
Learn More
Why I love this paw-fectly delightful flower
Kangaroo paws are not scented, nor particularly useful except in the most elegant of floral arrangements, the kind I can't…
Australian election 2022: Anthony Albanese ‘humbled’ to be next PM as voters abandon Coalition
Labor leader pledges to implement Uluru statement and to end climate wars, while Scott Morrison says he will stand down…
Lake Mac Arts website a 'one-stop-shop' for cultural events
"The diversity of what we have now is excellent, from opera to DJ sets to contemporary dance. A few years…
Tony Abbott and Scott Morrison have emptied the Liberals’ broad church
The party has been routed in its metropolitan heartland – the moderate wing has been decimated
From analysis to good news, read the world’s best news in one place
Western Australia: The state that made Anthony Albanese Australia’s next prime minister
Western Australia turned the tide in tight election to return Labor to power and make Anthony Albanese Australia's next prime…
Scott Morrison’s faithful downcast as second election miracle falls short
Soft aimless jazz replaces news coverage at the Liberal reception in Sydney with bewildered supporters trying to piece together what…

Alan Tudge, Scott Morrison and who knows what about Rachelle Miller’s reported $500,000 payout

By Katharine Murphy Political editor
Rachelle Miller
Rachelle Miller, the former aide to stood aside education minister Alan Tudge. Photograph: Lukas Coch/AAP

One of the stranger stories in this campaign has been the travails of Alan Tudge – Schrödinger’s minister – a person both in and out of Scott Morrison’s cabinet. Also strange: what the government has said at various times about the events that have contributed to this unusual state affairs. To help cut through the confusion, and in the interests of transparency, let’s work through this saga, step by step.

The allegation

Last year, the prime minister faced pressure to do something about Tudge. His former staffer Rachelle Miller alleged in December that Tudge had been emotionally and, in one instance, physically abusive towards her during a personal and professional relationship. Tudge denied Miller’s allegations and went to the backbench.

The Thom inquiry

Morrison then appointed the distinguished former bureaucrat Vivienne Thom to investigate whether or not there had been any breach of his ministerial standards. After an inquiry, Thom said there wasn’t “a basis for a finding that Mr Tudge’s conduct breached the ministerial standards”.

There were two footnotes. “The evidence available to the inquiry was limited by Ms Miller’s decision not to participate,” Thom wrote, and the ministerial standards “do not specifically address broader integrity and conflict of interest issues that can be a consequence of relationships that do not amount to ongoing or family relationships”.

Is that the only process involving Miller?

No. Separately to the issues canvassed by Thom, in November 2020, Miller filed a workplace harassment lawsuit seeking compensation for her treatment while a Liberal party staffer, including allegedly being belittled in Tudge’s office and deprived of further career progression after she was shuffled into the office of then employment minister Michaelia Cash.

This legal action is against the Department of Finance, which is technically the employer of ministerial staff.

There has been an attempt to mediate and reach a settlement, and press reports have pointed to the potential for Miller to receive a taxpayer-funded compensation payment of at least $500,000, plus legal costs.

But the process has stalled.

What has the government said? (We know nothing.)

Back in April, Morrison told 2GB he had no “visibility” on that workplace action. “Those are private matters between the department of finance and Ms Miller, and they’re appropriately at arm’s length from me,” he said.

Morrison said the “rules” meant he wasn’t “allowed to have visibility or any participation in that, because it’s an employment matter, and no one can confirm these issues”.

In mid-April, the Coalition’s campaign spokesperson Anne Ruston said the workplace action was “not related to the issues that were the subject of the Thom inquiry, which found Mr Tudge had not breached ministerial standards. My understanding is it’s a separate matter that’s being handled by the Department of Finance and you’ll need to direct your questions to them”.

Finance at that time declined to engage with specifics, saying it did not comment “on the details of any individual claim.”

We know something

But by Wednesday night, Morrison did have information.

During the final leaders’ debate of the campaign, the prime minister was asked by the Seven Network’s political editor Mark Riley “don’t taxpayers have a right to know why they have paid half a million dollars compensation to your education minister, Alan Tudge’s press secretary and former lover?”

Morrison said: “I’m advised [this action] has not even been settled. That’s because these are matters to go to very private interactions between people and they are handled sensitively.”

After he shared this information about the workplace matter, which is ongoing and unresolved, Morrison flipped back to the concluded Thom inquiry. “We had an independent inquiry into Alan Tudge,” Morrison said. “I had an independent inquiry. We dealt with the issue”.

Then a little later in the debate, Morrison veered back to the workplace action. “On the other matter of the financial settlement, I’m advised that the matter hasn’t even been settled.”

What has Tudge said?

Asked earlier this week why the Department of Finance was negotiating with Miller to receive a payment in excess of $500,000, Tudge said: “As the prime minister said, he’s unaware, I’m unaware. It’s a matter for the Department of Finance”.

“I have no information. I haven’t been called as a witness. I haven’t been asked to provide evidence and as the prime minister said, if it involved me, he would have been made aware and he hasn’t been made aware.”

Given the broad allegations levelled in Miller’s workplace claim have been reported publicly and widely in a number of media outlets, it is odd for Tudge to say he has no information. Presumably he means he hasn’t been formally engaged as part of any legal action.

Miller has been engaged in mediation with the Department of Finance – technically her former employer. She may yet launch a legal action that ventilates specific allegations against Tudge and Cash, but that hasn’t happened as yet.

What has Miller said?

While the government has said for several weeks either it hasn’t been briefed, or it would be inappropriate to respond in detail to questions about this action, Miller said in mid-April she was happy to release the commonwealth, the finance department and the prime minister from “any obligation of confidentiality in respect of her claim”.

Often the settlement of such claims include non-disclosure agreements. Miller has made it clear she isn’t interested in a settlement on those terms.

What did Morrison say on Thursday?

Morrison was asked on the hustings on Thursday whether he stood by a previous statement that the $500,000-plus compensation claim did not involve Tudge. He was asked: “If the Cabinet minister was involved in such a claim, you would be told?”

The prime minister said “that was the advice that I received from the secretary of the Department of Prime Minister and Cabinet”.

Morrison was then asked whether or not he was being briefed on the contents of the claim. “Well, I can’t be,” he said.

It was pointed out to the prime minister that a 22-page letter sent to the Department of Finance outlined specific allegations against the two ministers Miller worked for – Tudge and Cash. “I can’t be briefed on that,” Morrison said. “My only advice was that it hadn’t been settled. That was my last advice.”

A clarification and a conflation

Morrison then said something quite specific. He said if there was any matter “that went to the conduct of any minister, any minister at all, that related to the ministry or standards – then I would be advised of that”.

Having made that observation, Morrison then segued to the concluded Thom inquiry, which is different to the unconcluded workplace matter against the Department of Finance.

But the prime minister seemed to conflate the two processes. “We had an independent inquiry into those matters and that independent inquiry did not find any basis for any action in relation to the ministerial standards,” he said.

What happens from here?

Apart from ongoing confusion and a significant lack of transparency, it is not yet clear how this story ends.

Miller may settle her claim successfully, or she may take it to the courts.

What is inkl?
The world’s most important news, from 100+ trusted global sources, in one place.
Morning Edition
Your daily
news overview

Morning Edition ensures you start your day well informed.

No paywalls, no clickbait, no ads
Enjoy beautiful reading

Content is only half the story. The world's best news experience is free from distraction: ad-free, clickbait-free, and beautifully designed.

Expert Curation
The news you need to know

Stories are ranked by proprietary algorithms based on importance and curated by real news journalists to ensure that you receive the most important stories as they break.

Dive Deeper:
‘Had better days’: Alan Tudge’s single exchange with education department since standing down
Confusion has surrounded post of education minister since PM insisted Tudge was still in cabinet, despite standing aside
What the hell is going on with Alan Tudge?
The on-again/off-again education minister is a man of mystery — and it looks like the voting public will just have…
Alan Tudge emerges on WeChat to respond to questions about ‘toxic gender ideology’
Coalition MP, who has been absent from the campaign, stars in three-minute video telling voters to ‘think carefully who you…
Leaders' debate: Albanese wins final debate, Morrison confirms Tudge will re-enter cabinet if re-elected
Anthony Albanese wins the third leaders' debate which saw he and Scott Morrison cover well-trodden issues, but also the Prime…
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
A failure as shameful as robodebt leaves questions only a royal commission can examine
Without an understanding of how this unlawful scheme occurred, what’s to stop something similar happening again?
Female voters are queueing up to belt Scott Morrison, and it could get very ugly
The prime minister is on the nose with women, and it’s gone from bad to worse since the Brittany Higgins…
Get all your news in one place