For the first time in two years, Simonds Stadium was sold out as more than 28,000 AFL fans turned out to Geelong, about 75km south-west of Melbourne, to watch the Cats take on the Sydney Swans and the return of Adam Goodes to the game.
It was hard to tell if they were there owing to the focus on the Swans and Goodes over the past fortnight, or purely to cheer on their respective teams. But what was clear was the message from both teams to the crowd: barrack with respect.
As fireworks erupted, the players ran together through one banner emblazoned with the words “fairness, unity and respect”. Then there was the pre-match video from Geelong where players delivered the same message to the gathering crowd. On each side of the field behind the goalposts, Cats and Swans supporters held up the same sign, one red, one navy blue: “Be a Goodes sport. Say no to racism.”
It would have been difficult for Goodes not to have felt under pressure. But he should have felt more welcomed than nervous, with an overwhelming show of support for him despite the few critics who weighed in. Goodes felt compelled to sit out last week’s game as crowd taunts and cruel commentary peaked, but since then, expressions of solidarity towards the former Australian of the year have come in thick and fast.
The crowd, though not perfect, largely took heed of the call to be good sports on Saturday night. The bulk of any disappointment felt by the two-time Brownlow medallist and Indigenous ambassador would be owing to the result and not the audience, with Sydney ultimately going down to Geelong by 32 points.
There were a significant few hoping to rile up the crowd: on a ground dominated by Geelong fans seeing their team play on home turf, at times cries of “sook” and “harden up” could be heard as Goodes approached the boundary.
Kylie Wilmot, a Swans supporter who stuck out in the sea of navy blue, told Guardian Australia the sporadic taunts directed at Goodes were disappointing, but conceded: “The response to Goodes has been vastly better than it has been over the past few weeks. I’m just so happy to see him back out there, I don’t think it’s good for any supporter of any club to have seen someone as hardworking as Goodes sitting out.”
Lisa Cork, also barracking for the Swans, said she had noticed Cats fans gently turning on their own with pleas to “shush” at the rare times their peers had resorted to boos, even though their booing may not have been a dig at Goodes directly.
“A few people have reacted like that,” she said.
As the game began, a subdued, almost eerie atmosphere came over the ground, according to members of the Melbourne branch of the official Sydney Swans cheer squad. “It’s subdued out there, it’s tense,” said Debbie Budge. “You can tell the Swans are nervous.”
Her cheer buddy, Steve Pola, agreed. The Swans seemed nervous and overly eager to pass the ball to Goodes, he said. “It’s a strange atmosphere ... [but] Geelong are a polite crowd, a respectful crowd,” he said.
The tension lingered for the first quarter but lifted as the game entered the second, at which point the Swans were dominating in possessions and leading the Cats. A goal from Goodes late in the first quarter helped boost the team and their fans, and the crowd reaction as he scored was as would be expected from a Geelong home game.
That some people, however, were less than impressed with Goodes, was impossible to ignore. Some maintained a strong level of antagonism towards him. A few used derogatory language to describe him, though all rejected any suggestion their views were associated with racism.
When pressed, their reasoning revolved around a belief that Goodes was an attention seeker, which seemed odd since it was the crowd and their booing, not Goodes, that ensured all attention was on him for the past few weeks.
“He’s brought the game into disrepute,” said Geelong supporter Daniel Kent.
“He’s always trying to make it all about him. There are 71 other Aboriginal players and you don’t see them getting booed or making it about race if they do.”
But Brett Mollison was at the Swans versus West Coast match a couple of weeks back when the saga began as the booing of Goodes reached a crescendo, and, in a show of support for his teammate, Lewis Jetta threw an imaginary spear at the crowd. Mollison said it was awful to witness the way Goodes was treated throughout that game.
“The booing was unlike anything I’ve heard,” he said. “I wanted it to be over. It was terrible. I just wanted to crowd to shut up and be respectful.”
For most the part, however, the crowd on Saturday night was fair, he said.
Goodes may not have been proud of his team’s performance. Their second half was a mess. But supporters believe he should be proud of the conversation about racism that has resulted from his speaking out and the awareness that has been raised about the ongoing pain and harm racism leaves in its wake.
As the journalist Stan Grant explained in a comment piece for Guardian Australia: “To Adam’s ears, the ears of so many Indigenous people, these boos are a howl of humiliation. A howl that echoes across two centuries of invasion, dispossession and suffering.”
And the chairman of Tony Abbott’s Indigenous Advisory Council, Warren Mundine, was so affected by the experience of Goodes that he shared the impact of racism on his own life in a piece for the Spectator, while highlighting Goodes’ charitable work with Indigenous people and the broader community.
“Goodes’ professional achievements and charitable activities are easily on par with Ita Buttrose, Geoffrey Rush, Lee Kernaghan and other winners from the sports and entertainment industries,” Mundine wrote.
“For Goodes’ sake I hope the booing stops. But if it doesn’t, he should feel no less proud of his achievements. And Australians should be no less proud of him.”
Grant and Mundine were just two among an army of supporters who felt empowered to call racism out as a result of the experience of Goodes. But the real test of the way Australians respond to the views of Indigenous people will not come from Goodes’ return to the game he is so respected for playing.
Rather, what happens from here on in, and the way AFL management responds, will reveal whether Australians and those in positions of power have learned anything from Goodes. Certainly, the AFL and its chief executive, Gillon McLachlan, have had their share of critics over the past fortnight for what some have described as a refusal to call out fans behaving badly.
Future behaviour will be the real indication of whether people have simply temporarily toned it down or have truly begun to change their ways.
