Fight Night Champion was a hit, and ever since that game, boxing fans have been hungry for something equally immersive. For more than a decade, fans lacked a video game that took things to the ring as real as Fight Night Champion did — until Undisputed arrived in 2024.
As a full next-generation title, Undisputed handled things a lot differently. With highly realistic fighting mechanics, authentic presentation, and in-depth attention to detail, the game quickly rose to the top of the trends in the boxing community. Expectations were sky-high, and Undisputed strived to live up to them.
With the Tank vs Jake Paul fever currently at full swing, there’s no better time to discuss this boxing title. Undisputed was indeed promising, but after a year, does it still hold up?
What The Game Promised VS What It Delivered
Undisputed joined us after skipping the whole PS4/Xbox One era. Arriving for the current-gen consoles fueled hopes because creating a fighting game for powerhouses such as the PS5 and Xbox Series S|X meant the possibility of incorporating more features.
If you are a boxing enthusiast who is planning to dive into the game, having a look at the gameplay footage and images can instantly grab your attention. This is because Undisputed indeed lives up to its next-generation claim and is a visual eyecandy. But what about other crucial aspects? To keep up with the pace, here’s a table that compares pre-release promises with the post-release achievements of this boxing simulator.
| Aspects | Promises | Achievements |
| Gameplay Mechanics | Strategy-driven, in-depth simulation, and authentic boxing mechanics | Immersive core controls and punch impact, but overpowered counterattacks and inconsistent hit detection |
| Graphics | Full next-gen, authentic fighter models, world detail, and fluid animations | Just as promised, but with occasional inconsistent animations and a lackluster background |
| Commentary | Energetic, dynamic commentary fueling the fighting atmosphere | Can feel repetitive with less variety and depth |
| Roster | 70+ licensed stars with legends and active stars across genders | Around 100 licensed fighters, with many locked behind paid DLCs |
| Career Mode | Deep with narrative-driven cutscenes, strategic choices, and training | Felt basic with strategic choices and training. Lacks strong progression incentives |
| Online Mode | Showcased Competitive multiplayer, ranked matchmaking, and various playstyles | Strong and fun. Some technical issues with punch detection and balance |
| Post-Launch Support | Patches, content updates, enhancing gameplay, and increasing the roster | Slow, focusing more on paid DLC rather than gameplay enhancements and fixes |
| Monetization | Base game with access to almost everything | Costly DLCs for just fighters were frustrating |
Judging by the table, Undisputed does fulfill its promises, but partially. Graphics, core gameplay, roster size, and online mode really shine, almost as bright as the developers showcased. However, weird hit detection and unfair counterattacks may prevent players from having an ultimate boxing experience on their screens.
This isn’t it; commentary is a crucial aspect of any sport, let alone boxing, where the energy constantly skyrockets. With Undisputed delivering repetitive and shallow in-game commentary, enthusiasts didn’t feel as immersed. Plus, major superstars requiring a DLC further diminished the game’s spotlight.
But even with these issues, the game never fails to amaze. It’s as real as it gets with gameplay mechanics heavily inspired, if not a carbon copy of, an average boxing match. Go full-on Ryan versus Devin and immerse yourself in action-packed showdowns, hard to experience elsewhere.
Can The Championship Edition Make Up For The Issues?
With the announcement of the Undisputed Championship Edition, Steel City Interactive has cranked up our hopes once again. Undisputed is said to be treated with enhanced content and an overall polished experience. With the update dropping on October 21, 2025, players can expect new DLCs, including WBC, Iron & Steel, The Mexican Monster, and one yet-to-be-revealed pack, which will deliver loads of new fighters to the ring.
The Championship Edition also aims to listen to the fans and act upon their feedback. Improvements in gameplay mechanics and atmosphere will finally be made, elevating the overall experience that the current version lacks.
The boxing sim might finally solidify its place in esports and attract more players thanks to the new content. Judging by Undisputed’s plans, the game can finally live up to its name or even go beyond.
