Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
ABC News
ABC News
Sport
By Jon Healy

'A poor look for the game': Soliola not sent off despite sickening hit on Slater

With all the talk around the missing send-off rule in the AFL, referee Matt Cecchin has apparently forgotten the NRL does have one.

In the 51st minute of Melbourne's 20-14 win over the Raiders in Canberra, superstar full-back Billy Slater had his head rocked back by a swinging arm from late-to-arrive Raiders giant Sia Soliola.

While Slater was being carefully seen to by trainers, the replay of Soliola's high shot was shown repeatedly on the big screen at Canberra Stadium and on television telecasts.

Slater gave the thumbs up and was communicating with other players and trainers as they placed him on a board.

He eventually left the field on a medicab, while commentators both amateur and professional speculated that Soliola would be the first NRL player to get sent off in two years.

Coincidentally, the last send-off incident, in round 22 of the 2015 season, also involved a Canberra forward.

On that day, David Shillington headbutted Wests Tigers counterpart Aaron Woods and was given his marching orders, but Soliola's hit did not elicit the same response.

One of the commentators was former Canberra captain and current ABC Grandstand expert Alan Tongue, who labelled it "huge contact".

"It could be the end of Sia Soliola's night," he said.

"I know that [Slater] is falling in the tackle, but the contact is late and it's right with the head."

Tongue added: "He'll be gone. I think he will be for sure."

But Cecchin opted to allow Soliola to stay on the field, only putting him on report.

"If it's not a sending off, I don't know what is a sending off," Storm coach Craig Bellamy said after the game.

Among a number of people questioning the severity of the punishment was Storm chief executive Dave Donaghy.

He also said he had contacted the NRL powers that be "informing them we'll be asking the obvious question" later in the week.

But Donaghy was certainly not alone in expressing his confusion on social media …

Cecchin and the officials left the field flanked by security and to a chorus of boos from the stands.

Whether Cecchin should have sent Soliola for an early shower under the current rules will be debated until the cows come home, but the argument that the sin bin should be used for foul play will now surely return.

Bellamy drew that comparison in his post-match press conference after Melbourne lost Cameron Munster for 10 minutes later in the game for a professional foul for hanging around in the ruck.

"It just seems an incident like that happens and then you're on report — he's going to come under scrutiny without a doubt — but then we lose a player for holding onto someone," Bellamy said.

"I'm just not quite sure that's right and fair … that just seems a little bit not quite right."

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.