America is a nation of collectors. From vintage baseball cards and rare coins to antique firearms and old records, collectors take pride in scouring flea markets, auction houses, and estate sales in pursuit of elusive treasures. But not every collectible is fair game—there are some surprisingly off-limits items that can land even the most well-meaning hobbyist in serious legal trouble.
Laws vary by state and federal statute, and ignorance is not a defense when law enforcement comes knocking. For those passionate about collecting, it’s essential to know where curiosity crosses the line into illegality.
1. Bald Eagle Feathers
The bald eagle might be a majestic symbol of American freedom, but possessing even a single feather from this iconic bird is strictly prohibited under federal law. The Bald and Golden Eagle Protection Act makes it illegal to collect, sell, or even keep feathers, bones, or any part of a bald eagle without a special permit. This rule was enacted to help conserve eagle populations that were once endangered due to habitat loss and hunting.
Native American tribes can receive specific allowances through the National Eagle Repository, but those permissions don’t extend to the general public. Violators face steep fines, possible imprisonment, and the confiscation of the items in question.
2. Human Remains
It may come as a shock, but some collectors seek out human bones, skulls, and even mummified remains to add to their macabre collections. While there’s a black market for such items, possessing human remains without proper documentation or provenance is illegal in most U.S. states. Federal laws kick in when remains are stolen from Native American burial sites or archaeological digs, protected by the Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act.
Collecting or trading in human remains is not only unethical but also deeply disrespectful to the deceased and their descendants. Authorities treat such crimes seriously, and punishment can include hefty penalties and criminal charges.
3. Certain Types of Shells and Coral
The beautiful coral and rare seashells found along certain U.S. coastlines may seem like perfect beachcombing souvenirs, but collecting them can be against the law. Many species of coral are protected under the Endangered Species Act and the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species (CITES). Some shells, like the Queen Conch, are also protected, and taking them from their natural habitats can disrupt delicate marine ecosystems. National and state parks often have posted signs warning against collecting marine life, but tourists and collectors sometimes ignore them, risking fines and confiscation. It’s always wise to research local and federal laws before pocketing that eye-catching ocean treasure.
4. Artifacts from Public Lands
Hiking in the American Southwest or exploring old ghost towns might uncover intriguing items like arrowheads, pottery shards, or ancient tools—but removing them from public land is illegal. The Archaeological Resources Protection Act (ARPA) safeguards historical artifacts on federal lands from looting and unauthorized excavation.
Even if the object appears abandoned or worthless, it might be a significant piece of cultural history. Taking it disrupts archaeological research and disrespects the legacy of Indigenous peoples and early settlers. Law enforcement agencies actively monitor and prosecute those caught collecting or selling protected artifacts.
5. Military Equipment and Ordnance
Military enthusiasts often collect items like medals, uniforms, and decommissioned gear, but some items are absolutely off-limits. Collecting unexploded ordnance, grenades, or even empty shell casings from certain eras can violate federal explosives laws. Items like these are not only illegal to possess without a special license but also pose serious safety hazards. In some cases, well-meaning collectors have unknowingly brought home live explosives, leading to emergency evacuations and criminal investigations. Museums and certified institutions are typically the only places where such items can be legally stored and displayed.
6. Certain Animal Products
The fur trade might be legal in certain parts of the country, but there are specific animal products that cannot be collected, sold, or even owned in the U.S. Items made from tiger skins, rhino horns, ivory, and some exotic leathers are banned under the Endangered Species Act and other international treaties. The sale and collection of these items contribute to illegal poaching and the decline of endangered species worldwide. Even antique items made before these laws were enacted require documentation and permits to be legally traded. Collectors who violate these laws can face both federal charges and public backlash.
7. Meteorites on Government Land
Meteorite collecting is a growing hobby, but those cosmic treasures don’t always belong to the finder. On private land, a meteorite typically belongs to the landowner, but on public land—especially land managed by the Bureau of Land Management or the National Park Service—strict rules apply. Casual collection of small meteorite fragments is allowed in some cases, but commercial or large-scale collecting is prohibited without permits. Unauthorized collection can lead to the seizure of the meteorites and potential legal action. The government enforces these laws to ensure scientific research takes priority over private ownership.
8. Native American Sacred Objects
Some collectors seek out Native American cultural artifacts like masks, totems, and ceremonial items for their historical or artistic value, but many of these objects are protected under federal law. The Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act makes it illegal to own or trade sacred objects and funerary items that were obtained without tribal permission.
Museums and universities have had to return countless items to tribes under this law, even if the objects were acquired decades ago. These items are often considered spiritually significant and are not meant for private hands. Collecting them is not only illegal but also a serious violation of Indigenous sovereignty and respect.
9. Certain Plants and Seeds
It might be tempting for plant lovers to collect rare flora, but some plants are federally protected and illegal to remove from their natural environments. For example, wild ginseng is a highly regulated plant due to overharvesting, and collecting it without a permit can result in steep fines. Likewise, plants listed under the Endangered Species Act—such as the San Francisco manzanita or the Western prairie fringed orchid—are protected from disturbance or collection. The illegal trade in rare plants is a growing issue tied to habitat destruction and loss of biodiversity. For ethical and legal reasons, it’s essential to leave these plants where they grow.
The Strange, True Laws Of The U.S.
While collecting can be a deeply fulfilling hobby, it comes with legal responsibilities that should never be ignored. Many of the items listed above might seem like innocent treasures to the untrained eye, but their collection can harm ecosystems, disrespect cultures, or violate national security laws. Staying informed and researching the legality of each item is essential for any serious or casual collector.
The goal should always be to preserve, not exploit, the beauty and significance of the past and the natural world. Have thoughts on surprising things that are illegal to collect—or know of something not mentioned here? Leave a comment and join the conversation.
Read More
10 Things You Used To Be Able To Do That Are Now Heavily Regulated (Or Even Illegal)
From Hobby to Protection: How Knife Collections Can Be a Lifesaving Asset
The post 9 Surprising Things That Are Illegal to Collect in the U.S. appeared first on Clever Dude Personal Finance & Money.
