We all love Costco’s promise of bulk savings, but not every aisle delivers. There are plenty of Costco items not worth it, even if you’re a frequent shopper. Whether deals go bad before you can finish them or the quality isn’t up to scratch, some purchases come with hidden costs. Revealing these can help you maximize value and avoid waste. Read on to see which nine items you might want to skip—even if you’re already a member.
1. Organic English Cucumbers and Fresh Fruit
Buying fresh fruit and organic English cucumbers in bulk seems healthy, but they rarely get eaten before spoiling. Real Simple notes that produce often goes bad faster than a typical household can consume, especially for smaller families. Spoiled fruit is wasted money and adds to the food waste pile. Consider buying produce in smaller quantities at your local grocery store for better freshness and value. For perishables, less is often more.
2. Kirkland Signature Bagels & Bulk Cream Cheese
Creamy bagels and tubs of cream cheese are delicious—until they sit around past their prime. The Real Simple article warns that large packs of bagels and dairy can expire before you can finish them. Unless you’re feeding a crowd weekly, these items often become wasteful. Better to grab smaller bakery items elsewhere or freeze them immediately after opening. Bulk doesn’t always mean bargain.
3. Fresh Garlic and Soy Sauce Bottles
Buying fresh garlic in big jars or massive soy sauce bottles may seem practical, but flavor loss happens quickly. Garlic can sprout or include bad cloves before the jar is finished. Excess soy sauce left on your shelf may degrade in taste. Many customers regret these bulk buys simply because the product quality diminishes over time. Stick to smaller sizes for better pantry turnover.
4. Costco Windshield Wipers
Costco’s auto section seems trustworthy, but many customers report subpar windshield wipers that don’t last. Reddit users directly call these wipers out as disappointing purchases. Poor wipers compromise driving safety and require replacements, sometimes sooner than cheaper alternatives. Auto forums often advise buying name-brand wipers instead. Your car—and your wallet—will thank you.
5. Seasonal Produce: Strawberries & Cucumbers
Even when fresh, seasonal produce like strawberries and cucumbers is sold in huge quantities and spoils fast. Users on Reddit call strawberries “never worth” the bulk buy, noting rapid mold growth. These items are best bought locally in smaller quantities when peak freshness. With perishables, freshness matters more than wholesale packaging. It’s waste control 101.
6. Massive Cold Cut & Cheese Packs
Business Insider’s longtime Costco member warns that cold cuts and cheese go bad before you can use them, especially in families. Even love for sandwiches isn’t enough to eat through huge food trays. To reduce waste, people recommend buying smaller deli packs locally or using freezers better. Unless you’re hosting weekly lunches, steer younger families away from bulk deli.
7. Pre-Made Meals
Costco pre-made meals like Kirkland pulled pork or ready-to-eat entrées may seem convenient, but often aren’t so when compared to local grocery deals. According to Business Insider, local stores sometimes offer better prices for similar meals. Moreover, taste preferences can vary, and bulk entrées risk leftover dishes being wasted or forgotten. Save your freezer space and sanity by comparing local alternatives before stocking up.
8. Large K-Cup Packs
Coffee lovers rejoice at bulk K-Cups, but variety is everything. One couple complains that a 100-pack took over their pantry—and palates. If you like flavor variety, buying smaller boxes of single-serve pods might be smarter. And spending a little more for choice beats being stuck with coffee fatigue. Coffee flexibility > bulk boredom.
9. Single-Use Patio Furniture and Seasonal Décor
Costco’s seasonal items can be eye candy, but often wear out quickly or fail to survive the season. The Sun’s story of a former member cites impulse buys of vests and patio furniture as part of the regret. Cheap-looking items may not hold up, forcing early replacement. Save space, money, and disappointment by sticking to quality seasonal purchases. Trends fade—good design lasts.
Rethink the Membership: Value Over Volume
Not all Costco items not worth it are bad—they’re just misaligned with your needs. Bulk deals only pay off when you can use and store them properly. Regularly review your membership spending: Are you actually saving or just spending more? Costco works best for staple items like eggs, toilet paper, and bulk proteins. For perishables, variety, or seasonal items, other stores might be smarter bets.
Costco isn’t going anywhere—but smart shopping means knowing which Costco items are not worth it cost more than you think. Go in with a plan: list items you go through fast, skip those that spoil, and compare unit prices. If you can’t finish something before it expires, skip it. Your membership could save you money if you shop carefully.
Did you ever regret a Costco purchase? Share your story in the comments and help others avoid the same bulk blunders!
Read More
5 Costco Snacks With More Complaints Than Sales
7 Grocery Items Costco Members Are Complaining About in 2025
The post 9 Costco Items That Aren’t Worth Renewing Your Membership For appeared first on Grocery Coupon Guide.
