Trust and mutual care build strong relationships. But sometimes, you get a nagging feeling that someone’s support isn’t genuine. They say all the right things, but their actions tell a different story. This emotional dissonance can be confusing and hurtful. Recognizing the signs of someone pretending to care is crucial for protecting your emotional well-being. Ultimately, it helps you invest your energy in people who truly value you.
Her Words and Actions Don’t Match
This is the most significant red flag. For instance, she might say, “I’m always here for you.” However, when you actually need her, she’s suddenly busy. She’ll promise to call back but never does. This disconnect between promises and reality is a clear signal. After all, true care is demonstrated through action, not just comforting words.
Therefore, you must pay attention to the patterns. Of course, anyone can have a one-time flake. But a consistent failure to show up speaks volumes. People who genuinely care make an effort. In short, their actions align with their supportive language. If they don’t, you’re likely dealing with someone who is just pretending to care.
She Only Reaches Out When She Needs Something
First, consider the nature of your conversations. Does she only call when she needs a favor, like borrowing something or getting advice? Then, once you meet her need, she disappears again until the next time. This one-sided dynamic reveals a transactional relationship, not a supportive one.
In contrast, a person who truly cares will check in just because. They will ask how you are without an ulterior motive. Moreover, they celebrate your wins and support you through your losses. If the communication always stems from her needs, the relationship is about her convenience, not your connection.
Conversations Are Always About Her
Imagine you start to share something about your day. Before you can finish, she has already pivoted the conversation back to herself. Your promotion reminds her of a success she had. Similarly, your problem reminds her of a much bigger problem she once faced. This conversational hijacking is a clear sign of self-absorption.
People who are pretending to care often use you as a sounding board. In reality, they are not interested in a dialogue. They want a monologue with an audience. On the other hand, a genuine friend practices active listening. They ask follow-up questions and show sincere interest in your life.
Her “Support” Feels Performative or Vague
When you’re upset, she might offer generic platitudes. For example, you might hear a quick “That’s tough” or “It’ll get better.” There’s no real substance or empathy behind her words. In fact, her support feels like she’s reading from a script. It’s performative and lacks any genuine warmth.
Sincere support, however, is specific and engaged. A caring person might say, “I’m so sorry you’re dealing with that. What can I do to help?” They offer concrete assistance or a listening ear. Vague, dismissive comments are a low-effort way of pretending to care without actually doing so.
Trust Your Gut Over Their Words
Your intuition is a powerful tool. If you consistently feel drained, unseen, or unimportant in a relationship, you should listen to that feeling. People can say anything, but their energy and actions reveal the truth. Therefore, stop making excuses for someone’s behavior. Instead, start investing in relationships that are reciprocal, authentic, and genuinely supportive. You deserve to be cared for, not just managed.
Have you ever dealt with someone who was pretending to care? Share your experience in the comments.
What to Read Next…
- 10 Hidden Costs of Pretending Everything’s Fine in a Broken Relationship
- 5 Telltale Signs Shes Addicted to a Chaotic Relationship
- Why Dating in the 80s and 90s Left Us With These 7 Terrible Relationship Habits
- 11 Relationship Rules Therapists Wish You’d Break
- Is Your Relationship Built on Real Intimacy or Just Routine
The post 8 Signs She’s Pretending to Care (But Doesn’t) appeared first on Budget and the Bees.
