When homeowners think of adding value to their property, garage upgrades often seem like a safe bet. However, not all garage improvements translate into higher resale prices, especially in certain states. Market preferences, climate factors, and local buyer expectations can make some upgrades a drawback rather than a perk. For example, what’s considered practical in Florida might be a liability in Colorado. So, don’t make the mistake of making these eight garage upgrades! It could seriously hurt your resale value.
1. Converting the Garage into a Living Space
In states with colder winters or limited parking, buyers tend to view garages as essential. Removing this space for an extra bedroom, gym, or home office can backfire in these markets. It eliminates secure parking and valuable storage—two features buyers often prioritize. Even if the conversion is high-quality, appraisers in some regions won’t value it as highly as the original garage. Before committing, research local market trends to see if this upgrade aligns with buyer demand.
2. Overly Customized Flooring
Epoxy-coated or tiled garage floors can be visually appealing, but overly flashy designs can alienate potential buyers. In some states, buyers prefer a clean, basic concrete finish they can customize themselves. Intricate patterns, bold colors, or expensive imported tiles can be viewed as unnecessary or even impractical for heavy-use areas. Additionally, some buyers worry about durability or replacement costs. When in doubt, keep flooring upgrades simple and neutral to maintain broader appeal.
3. Adding Costly Built-In Cabinets
High-end built-in cabinets can be a dream for car enthusiasts or hobbyists, but they can feel restrictive to the average buyer. In certain states, where garages are primarily for vehicles, buyers may see these as space-wasting features. Permanent cabinetry limits flexibility for large vehicles, storage rearrangements, or alternative uses. The cost of removing or modifying them can also turn buyers off. Modular, removable storage solutions are often a safer investment.
4. Installing a Climate Control System
Adding heating or air conditioning to a garage might seem like a luxury upgrade, but it can be a red flag in some regions. In states with milder climates, buyers may see this as unnecessary and potentially expensive to maintain. In fact, climate control in a garage can raise questions about energy efficiency and monthly utility bills. Some appraisers won’t assign much added value to the system, making it more of a personal indulgence than a resale booster. Unless you’re in an area where climate-controlled garages are the norm, it may not pay off.
5. Choosing Specialty Lighting Over Function
Showroom-style lighting, such as LED strips or color-changing fixtures, can be a hit with car enthusiasts but a miss with the general market. In states where garages are primarily functional, buyers want practical, bright, and energy-efficient lighting. Specialty lighting may seem excessive or high-maintenance to those who just need a space to park and store items. Over-customization can make it harder for buyers to envision the space as their own. Opting for versatile lighting is usually a better bet.
6. Removing the Garage Door for Glass Panels
Swapping a standard garage door for a glass-paneled version can look sleek and modern, but it’s not ideal in all states. In colder regions, glass panels can compromise insulation and drive up heating bills. They can also pose privacy concerns, making it easy for outsiders to see valuables inside. Some homeowners’ associations even restrict them due to security risks. Before making this change, consider the climate, neighborhood style, and buyer expectations in your state.
7. Turning the Space into a Workshop
For hobbyists, a fully equipped workshop is a dream, but it can be a dealbreaker for others. In states where garages are primarily seen as storage or parking areas, extensive workbenches and machinery can feel like clutter. Buyers may also worry about noise, dust, and safety hazards. Removing a workshop setup before selling can be costly and time-consuming. If resale value is a priority, keep workshop upgrades portable and temporary.
8. Adding a Car Lift in a Small Garage
A car lift can be a must-have for auto enthusiasts, but it’s not always market-friendly. In states where larger garages are rare, a lift can make the space feel cramped and unusable for typical buyers. Some may see it as an expensive feature they’ll never use, making the home less appealing. It can also raise safety concerns for families with children. Unless you’re in a niche market where buyers expect it, a car lift may be better as a removable addition.
Making Smart Garage Upgrade Decisions for Resale
Not every improvement will boost your property’s market value, and when it comes to garage upgrades, less is often more. The key is to think like a buyer in your specific state—what’s desirable in Texas might be a dealbreaker in Vermont. Focus on versatile, functional improvements that appeal to a wide range of potential homeowners. Avoid over-customizing unless you plan to stay long-term and enjoy the features yourself. By aligning upgrades with market demand, you can protect your resale value and still enjoy your space.
Have you ever made a home upgrade you later regretted? Share your experience and thoughts in the comments below.
Read More
Are You Using a Garage Door Opener That’s Now Considered a Risk Device?
7 Garage Mistakes That Could Be Driving Your Electric Bill Up
The post 8 Garage Upgrades That Lower Resale Value in Some States appeared first on Clever Dude Personal Finance & Money.
