The words “electroshock therapy” can stir up instant unease. Flickering images of restrained patients, cold metal tables, and clinical indifference still haunt the public imagination, fueled by media portrayals and historical accounts. Electroconvulsive therapy (ECT), as it’s now called, has undergone significant reform over the decades, but its past is deeply rooted in controversial practices and questionable ethics. It was once seen as a miracle solution to mental illness, a way to jolt the suffering back to sanity. But behind that optimistic facade lies a history riddled with abuse, experimentation, and misunderstood science.
This therapy may have saved lives, but it also destroyed some. Understanding its disturbing past is essential—not to demonize modern psychiatry, but to ensure history doesn’t repeat itself.
1. It Was Inspired by Seizures in Schizophrenic Patients
The origins of electroshock therapy are based on a troubling assumption. In the early 20th century, psychiatrists noticed that patients with epilepsy who experienced seizures rarely showed signs of schizophrenia. This observation led to the dangerous theory that inducing seizures might cure mental illnesses like schizophrenia. Hungarian psychiatrist Ladislas Meduna experimented with chemical convulsions in the 1930s, before electric shocks were introduced. His early tests involved injecting patients with camphor and other convulsants, resulting in violent seizures, injuries, and sometimes death.
2. The First Use of Electricity Was Brutal and Unregulated
When Italian neurologists Ugo Cerletti and Lucio Bini introduced electricity as a way to induce seizures in 1938, the method was anything but gentle. Early treatments were conducted without anesthesia or muscle relaxants, meaning patients would thrash violently, often breaking bones or dislocating joints. There were no real safety standards, and voltage levels were essentially guessed. The main goal was to produce a seizure, not protect the patient’s physical well-being. These uncontrolled and brutal procedures set the stage for decades of fear and trauma associated with the therapy.
3. Electroshock Was Once Used to Punish and Control
ECT wasn’t always used with healing in mind—it was often a tool for compliance. In psychiatric institutions during the mid-20th century, electroshock was used to silence “unruly” patients or punish those who resisted authority. The therapy became a disciplinary measure rather than a medical intervention. Patients, many of whom had no true psychiatric diagnosis, were subjected to repeated shocks simply for being difficult, defiant, or even just poor. In these cases, it was less about curing mental illness and more about enforcing obedience in vulnerable populations.
4. It Targeted Women Disproportionately
Throughout its most controversial period, electroshock therapy was disproportionately administered to women. Many female patients were labeled “hysterical” or “emotionally unstable” for behaviors now considered completely normal, such as postpartum depression or anxiety. In an era where women’s mental health issues were often minimized or misunderstood, ECT became a go-to method for silencing and controlling them. Housewives who struggled with domestic expectations were particularly vulnerable to being institutionalized and shocked. This gender bias paints a chilling picture of how societal norms influenced psychiatric treatment.
5. Memory Loss Was Ignored or Downplayed
One of the most disturbing side effects of early ECT was memory loss—sometimes temporary, but often permanent. Patients reported forgetting significant parts of their lives, including their careers, relationships, and identities. In many cases, this memory damage was not just a side effect but a devastating erasure of self. Doctors at the time often dismissed these complaints or failed to document them seriously. The attitude was that curing depression justified almost any cost, including the loss of memories that made a person who they were.
6. It Was Popularized Before Its Risks Were Understood
ECT spread rapidly across Europe and the United States in the 1940s and 1950s, long before the long-term effects were properly studied. There was immense pressure on psychiatrists to find fast solutions for overcrowded asylums and a rising tide of mental illness. Electroshock offered quick, visible results, often making patients calmer and more manageable after a few sessions. But many of those improvements were short-lived, and relapse rates were high. The therapy was adopted en masse with minimal critical evaluation, turning experimentation into widespread practice.
7. Famous Victims and Whistleblowers Were Silenced
Over the decades, numerous celebrities and everyday individuals have spoken out about the trauma they experienced from ECT. Author Ernest Hemingway famously said the therapy “ruined” his memory and contributed to his depression and eventual suicide. Actress Frances Farmer, long considered a tragic figure in Hollywood, was subjected to forced electroshock that damaged her career and reputation. Those who spoke out were often dismissed as unstable or ungrateful. As institutions worked to protect their image, real stories of abuse were buried or discredited.
A Cautionary Legacy
Electroshock therapy has evolved considerably and is now more controlled, humane, and even effective for certain severe psychiatric conditions. But its history remains a stark reminder of how easily science can cross ethical lines when desperation outweighs caution. The disturbing truths behind ECT’s past reveal more than just outdated medical practices—they reflect a broader societal failure to protect the vulnerable. Reckoning with this history is necessary not only for accountability, but to ensure that psychiatry continues progressing with empathy and consent at its core.
What are your thoughts on electroshock therapy’s dark legacy? Drop a comment and join the conversation.
Read More
10 Medical Tests That Are Overhyped—and Sometimes Dangerous
Reports of Patient Safety Violations at U.S. Hospitals: What Inspections Reveal
The post 7 Disturbing Truths About the History of Electroshock Therapy appeared first on Everybody Loves Your Money.
