When you create a will or an estate plan, you are making a clear statement about your legacy. You believe you are setting down a final, unchangeable set of instructions for who gets your property and how your affairs should be handled. Most people assume that their signed will is the final word. However, the legal system has a complex set of checks and balances designed to protect certain individuals, and these protections can sometimes directly conflict with the wishes you’ve written down. A number of family members have special legal standing that can allow them to challenge your will in court. In certain situations, they can successfully block your final wishes, even if your intentions were perfectly clear.
Here are six types of family members who may have the power to overturn your will.
1. A Current Spouse (Even If You’re Separated)
This is the most powerful challenger to any will. Nearly every state has laws that protect a surviving spouse from being completely disinherited. This is known as the “spousal elective share.” Even if your will explicitly states that you leave your entire estate to your children or a charity, your legal spouse can petition the probate court to ignore the will and claim a legally mandated portion of your assets. This share is typically one-third to one-half of the “augmented estate.” This right exists even if you were separated and living apart for years, as long as you were not legally divorced at the time of your death.
2. A Child Who Was Left Out of the Will
While you generally have the right to disinherit a child, it must be done with extreme care and precision. If you simply omit a child’s name from your will, they may be able to challenge it under what is known as a “pretermitted heir” statute. This law is designed to protect against accidental disinheritance. The child can argue that you simply forgot to include them and that it was not your true intention to cut them out. To successfully disinherit a child, your will must state your intention to do so explicitly and unambiguously (e.g., “I intentionally make no provision in this will for my son, John, and it is my express wish that he takes nothing from my estate.”).
3. A Child Born After the Will Was Signed
This is a specific and common type of pretermitted heir. A person might write a will when they have two children, leaving their property to them equally. Years later, they have a third child but forget to update their will. When they die, the will only names the first two children. The law presumes that this was an oversight, not an intentional disinheritance. In this situation, a court will almost always rule that the third child is entitled to receive an equal share of the estate, effectively altering the specific instructions of the original document to block your final wishes as they were written.
4. A Common-Law Spouse
In the handful of states that still recognize common-law marriage (such as Colorado, Texas, and Utah), a long-term, unmarried partner can have the same legal rights as a traditional spouse. If a couple has held themselves out to the public as married, lived together, and intended to be married, a court can declare them legally married, even without a license or ceremony. If this is established after one partner’s death, the surviving common-law spouse can claim the same powerful spousal elective share, giving them the right to override the will and inherit a significant portion of the estate.
5. A Creditor with a Legitimate Claim
While not a family member in the traditional sense, a creditor is part of the “family” of individuals who have a legal claim to the estate. Your will might leave a beautiful house to your child, but your first legal obligation after death is to your creditors. The executor of your estate is legally required to use the estate’s assets to pay all legitimate debts—including mortgages, taxes, medical bills, and credit card balances—*before* any property can be distributed to the beneficiaries named in your will. If the estate’s debts are large, assets may have to be sold to pay them, which can block your final wishes for who gets what.
6. The Person You Named as Your Agent Under a Power of Attorney
This is a more subtle but dangerous conflict. A Power of Attorney (POA) is a document that gives a person (your “agent”) the power to manage your finances while you are alive. This power can be misused. For example, an agent could use the POA to change the beneficiary designations on your bank accounts, naming themselves as the sole beneficiary. This is a breach of their fiduciary duty, but it can be very difficult to prove after you have died. In this case, the agent’s self-serving actions before your death have effectively blocked your final wishes, as the beneficiary designation will override what’s in your will.
Your Will Is Not an Infallible Document
Creating a will is a critical step in protecting your legacy, but it is not a simple DIY project. The law is filled with complex rules and protections that can have unintended consequences for your estate plan. The only way to ensure your will is ironclad and can withstand a potential legal challenge is to work with an experienced estate planning attorney. They can help you navigate the nuances of spousal rights, disinheritance, and beneficiary designations. This proactive step ensures that your true intentions are honored and that no one can legally block your final wishes.
Have you ever witnessed a family dispute over a will? Share what you learned from the experience in the comments.
What to Read Next…
- 10 Moments When a Will Doesn’t Prevent Probate Pain
- What Makes a Will Useless in Probate Court
- The Vintage Tax Rule That Could Trigger Your Immediate Estate Levy
- 6 Hidden Documents That Change Everything After a Loved One Passes
- 7 Reasons Certain Canceled Wills Still Result in Court Battles
The post 6 Family Members Who Might Legally Block Your Final Wishes appeared first on Budget and the Bees.
