Finding good stocking stuffers that don’t look cheap is tricky. You want something that feels thoughtful without spending $50 per person, especially when you’re buying for multiple people. Sephora actually has a solid selection of beauty and self-care items under $10 that work perfectly for stockings.
Check Out: 9 Little Luxuries From Target That Make Great Stocking Stuffers
Read Next: 6 Things You Must Do When Your Savings Reach $50,000
Here are six picks that won’t cost you an arm and a leg but still feel like real gifts. Happy stocking stuffer shopping!
Sephora Collection Moisturizing Cherry Lip Mask
- Price: $3
At three bucks, this is probably the most affordable item on the list, but it doesn’t feel like a throwaway gift. The cherry-scented lip mask comes in a small container that’s perfect for tossing in a purse or keeping on a nightstand. Winter dries out everyone’s lips, so this is actually useful. Plus, at this price point, you could grab several and still stay under $20 total.
Explore More: 5 Little Luxuries From Costco That Make Great Stocking Stuffers
Sephora Collection Lip Sleeping Mask
- Price: $8
If you want to spend a little more on someone who takes their skin care seriously, the overnight lip treatment is a smart pick. It comes in a caramel macchiato scent, which sounds weird for lip care but apparently people love it. You apply it before bed and wake up with softer lips. It’s the kind of product people don’t always buy for themselves but appreciate getting as a gift.
Sephora Collection Exfoliating Lip Scrub in Dragonfruit
- Price: $7
Lip scrubs make great stocking stuffers because they’re small, useful and slightly indulgent. This dragonfruit version helps get rid of dead skin before you put on lipstick or lip balm. It’s especially good for winter when everyone’s dealing with chapped lips. The (delicious!) dragonfruit scent makes it feel more special than your basic lip care products.
Sephora Collection 3-in-1 Pencil Sharpener
- Price: $6
This might seem boring, but if you’re shopping for someone who wears makeup regularly, a good sharpener is genuinely useful. The 3-in-1 design works for different pencil sizes, from thin eyeliners to thicker lip pencils. Makeup people always need sharpeners and never seem to have one when they need it, so this solves an actual problem.
Sephora Collection Hand Balm With Shea Butter
- Price: $6
Winter destroys everyone’s hands, especially if you wash them a lot or work with your hands. This shea butter hand balm is small enough to fit in a stocking but substantial enough to actually help with dry skin. It absorbs quickly without leaving your hands greasy, which matters if you’re giving it to someone who’s constantly on their phone or typing.
Sephora Collection Caramel Macchiato Eye Mask
- Price: $4
For four dollars, these eye masks are perfect for rounding out a stocking without spending much. They’re designed for under-eye care and come in individual packets, which makes them good for travel or just a random night when you want to feel fancy. The caramel macchiato theme is cute without being ridiculous, and self-care items always make decent gifts.
Editor’s note: Pricing is accurate as of Dec. 5, 2025. Pricing and availability are subject to change.
More From GOBankingRates
- 5 Luxurious Winter Clothing Items You Can Find at Costco for Less
- 5 Little Luxuries To Buy at Dollar Tree This December
- 9 Downsizing Tips for the Middle Class To Save on Monthly Expenses
- 7 Ways Your Paycheck Indicates If You're Rich or Middle Class
This article originally appeared on GOBankingRates.com: 6 Best Stocking Stuffers From Sephora for Less Than $10
