The desire to feel safe is a core human need. But for women, let’s be honest, that desire is often a daily, active, exhausting concern. We are taught from the time we are little girls to be hyper-aware: walk with your keys between your fingers, don’t wear your hair in a ponytail, and avoid walking alone at night. We’re told not to make eye contact. Don’t, don’t, don’t. Ultimately, this constant, low-grade fear has fueled a booming market for personal safety devices.
These products are marketed brilliantly, promising empowerment, peace of mind, and protection in a tiny, pink package. The harsh reality? Some of the most popular devices are utterly ineffective. Even worse, they are actively dangerous. In truth, they provide a false, paper-thin sense of security. In a real, violent, chaotic attack, they are more likely to be taken and used against you. Here are five personal safety devices women should seriously reconsider.
1. A Knife (Including Those ‘Tactical Pens’)
This is, without a doubt, the worst idea. Carrying a knife for self-defense is something self-defense experts unanimously scream against. To be clear, a knife is a lethal weapon, not a defensive “get off me” tool. To use it effectively, you don’t just need a little practice; you need extensive, specialized training in the brutal art of knife-fighting. Without that, a 3-inch blade has zero stopping power.
Furthermore, an attacker is not going to be scared off by it. Instead, they are going to escalate their own violence to match the lethal threat you just introduced. The most likely scenario? They will disarm you in a second. And now, they have your knife. In effect, you have just brought a deadly weapon to a fight and handed it to your opponent, making a terrifying situation infinitely worse.
2. Kubotans or Pointed ‘Cat’ Keychains
A Kubotan is a small, pointed stick. You’ve seen them, or their cuter, more marketable “cat” or “dog” versions where you put your fingers through the eyes. The idea is to jab an attacker’s pressure points or bones. However, like a knife, this device requires a ton of skill. You need to know exactly where to strike, and you need the strength and precision to do it while someone is trying to harm you.
Let’s be realistic. Most women have these dangling from a crowded, jangling keychain at the bottom of a purse. In a sudden, violent ambush, you will not have time to fish for your keys, let alone get a proper grip. Consequently, fumbling for a cute, pointed keychain is a deadly distraction. That second of fumbling is the opening an attacker needs to gain control.
3. A Whistle
This is a classic, non-violent recommendation. The theory is you blow the whistle, someone hears it, and they come running to your aid. Unfortunately, this relies on a dangerously optimistic assumption: that people will intervene. It’s called the “bystander effect.” For example, people hear a noise, they get curious, but they almost always assume someone else will handle it. They might just think it’s kids playing.
Ultimately, a whistle is a passive alert. It does absolutely nothing to stop the person who is physically attacking you right now. An attacker can silence a whistle in a fraction of a second. In that moment, you have just wasted your most precious, powerful resource: your voice. Screaming “FIRE!” or “STOP! GET OFF ME!” at the top of your lungs is infinitely more effective. After all, it’s specific, it’s human, and it’s far more likely to jolt people into action.
4. A Handgun (Without Constant, Obsessive Training)
This is a controversial one, but it needs to be said. A firearm can be an effective equalizer. But—and this is a massive but—a gun is not a magic wand you buy and forget about. Owning a gun for self-defense isn’t a purchase; it’s a massive, ongoing, and expensive lifestyle commitment. Specifically, it requires hundreds of hours of range time and tactical training.
You must practice drawing from concealment under stress and clearing jams. Moreover, you must be mentally prepared, 100%, to take a human life. If you are not all of those things, that gun is a liability. In all likelihood, it will be taken from you and used against you. In short, a gun you are not ruthlessly proficient with is infinitely more dangerous to you than to an attacker.
5. Pepper Spray (When It’s Lost in Your Purse)
Wait, pepper spray? But that’s the one everyone recommends! Here’s the catch: Pepper spray is one of the most effective non-lethal tools available. It’s on this list, however, because of how women carry it. The spray is 100% useless if it’s clipped to a keychain in your pocket. Similarly, it’s useless if it’s in a side pocket of your backpack. And it’s absolutely useless if it’s at the bottom of your purse.
An attack happens in seconds, not minutes. You will not have time to say “excuse me” and dig for it. If you choose to carry pepper spray, it must be in your hand, with your thumb on the trigger, before you enter a sketchy situation. For instance, walking through a dark parking garage? It’s in your hand. Walking to your car late at night? It’s in your hand. If it’s not instantly accessible, then it’s a completely useless good-luck charm.
The Best Weapon You Have Is Your Mind
These devices all fail for one reason: they are a substitute for a plan. The most powerful personal safety tool you will ever own is your awareness. Specifically, it’s your intuition. It’s that “something feels wrong” feeling in your gut. It’s also your ability to avoid the confrontation in the first place. Your mind and your voice are your primary weapons. Therefore, trust your gut. If a situation feels off, leave. Immediately. Your safety is always more important than being polite.
What are your thoughts on personal safety devices? Do you agree or disagree with this list? Share your opinion below.
What to Read Next…
- 10 Women’s Safety Devices Every Woman Should Carry
- 9 Travel Experiences That Teach Women Safety Lessons
- 7 Travel Safety Rules Women Rarely Practice Abroad
- 10 Uber Rides Safety Rules Every Woman Needs Right Now
- 9 Reasons Every Woman Needs an Escape Fund
The post 5 Personal Safety Devices Women Believe They Need But Should NEVER Own appeared first on Budget and the Bees.
