If you’re a retiree planning to refresh your fall wardrobe at Old Navy, there are a few pieces you’ll want to avoid putting in your cart.
Explore More: 5 Best Items To Buy at Old Navy Now for the Second Half of 2025 To Save Big Money
Check Out: How Much Money Is Needed To Be Considered Middle Class in Your State?
Although Old Navy has some great deals on clothing basics, some of their offerings are closer to fast-fashion flops, with pieces that start falling apart after a few wears or sizing discrepancies that make it hard to find the right fit.
SoSoft Cropped Puff-Sleeve Sweater
- Price: $27.99
Fall is the perfect time to start pulling out sweaters. While you might be tempted to pick up this cropped puff-sleeve sweater from Old Navy, it might not be worth it. The sweater is made from cotton, recycled polyester and nylon, and that combination could mean intense pilling after a few wears.
Unless you’re ready to shave down the pilling, it might be better to choose a wool or cashmere option that will last you a few years instead. This one from Nordstrom is made from 70% wool and 30% cashmere, and even though it’s a higher price point, it’ll save you from having to buy the same sweater twice over.
Read Next: Amazon, Costco and 7 Other Stores With Perks That Retirees Should Cash In
Crew-Neck Flag-Graphic Sweater
- Price: $34.99
This Old Navy sweater is reminiscent of the iconic Ralph Lauren sweater that retails for nearly $400. However, just because it looks like Ralph Lauren doesn’t mean the quality is the same. Multiple Old Navy shoppers shared photos of the crew-neck flag sweater ripping right near the corner of the flag. One customer even shared that it ripped after the first wash.
If you’re going to spend $35, you may as well purchase something that’s going to last. Instead, you could go for this 100% organic cotton flag sweater from Quince for $59.90.
Flutter-Sleeve Sweater
- Price: $13.97 (reg. $34.99)
When you need transitional pieces for the early days of fall when it’s not quite chilly yet, you might be considering this trendy flutter sleeve sweater from Old Navy. However, the material it’s made from is prone to snags that aren’t easy to repair.
Extra High-Waisted CloudComfy 7/8 Leggings
- Price: $14.99
You’re staying active in retirement, and that means you’ll need leggings that can carry you through your fall workouts. Although the 50% off discount is tempting on these CloudComfy leggings, you might not want them once you realize they don’t pass the squat test. While other Old Navy leggings will serve you well, these are too see-through to be functional during a typical workout.
High-Waisted Wow Super-Skinny Jeans
- Price: $22.00 (reg. $34.99)
Looking for new jeans to add to your fall wardrobe? You may want to skip these Wow high-waisted super skinny jeans from Old Navy, even though they’re currently on sale for 37% off. Unfortunately, there are tons of reviews regarding an odd fit for these jeans. Reviewers share that the ankles are too loose for a true skinny jean fit, and it’s too tight around the calves, while also being baggy around the bottom area. Instead, you might want to choose the high-waisted vintage slim jeans from Old Navy, which have better reviews on fit and are still on sale right now.
Overall, stylish, cheap and cozy doesn’t always equal smart — especially on a fixed budget or when you’re counting on longevity. When you first purchase these Old Navy items, it may feel good, but it might not stay good for long.
Disclaimer: Prices and availability accurate as of August 30, 2025 and subject to change.
Photo disclaimer: All imagery sourced from OldNavy.com.
More From GOBankingRates
- 5 Little Luxuries To Buy at Dollar Tree This August
- 6 Summer Clothing Items You Should Buy at Costco Now
- How Far $750K Plus Social Security Goes in Retirement in Every US Region
- Warren Buffett: 10 Things Poor People Waste Money On
This article originally appeared on GOBankingRates.com: 5 Old Navy Items Retirees Should Avoid This Fall
