Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
USA Today Sports Media Group
USA Today Sports Media Group
Sport
Jordy McElroy

12 most shockingly embarrassing on-field moments in Patriots’ history

Patriots Tom Brady NFL Mac Jones Bill Belichick Eagles Giants Eli Manning Malcolm Butler Nick Foles

The New England Patriots’ franchise is one of the most revered organizations in the NFL, but it has also fallen victim to some truly shocking and embarrassing moments on the football field.

Fortunately, Patriots fans have the bragging rights of six Super Bowl victories to keep the haters at bay.

But there have obviously been moments during the coach Bill Belichick era and beyond that would be better off forgotten. Sadly, some of those moments happened last season with the Patriots falling off a cliff offensively and missing the playoffs.

In no particular order, we’re going to get into some of the 12 most shockingly embarrassing on-field moments throughout the Patriots’ franchise history. Be sure and follow Patriots Wire on Facebook and Twitter to let us know of any other moments you feel like deserve to be on this list.

Super Bowl XX blowout loss vs Bears

The defense for the 1986 Bears team was more impenetrable than Gringotts.

So few expected the Patriots to actually win Super XX. Not only did the Patriots lose on the big stage, they got blown off the field in a 46-10 loss. Imagine making it all the way to a championship game just to have the season end like that.

Ouch.

The lateral heard 'round the world

If “Shaqtin’ a Fool” was an NFL segment, the embarrassing lateral turnover in the Patriots’ 2022 loss to the Las Vegas Raiders would be at the top of the list for Shaquille O’Neil, Charles Barkley and Kenny Smith to roast relentlessly.

The worst part is the fact that none of it was even necessary. The Patriots could have simply downed the ball and taken the game into overtime. But Rhamondre Stevenson played hot potato with Jakobi Meyers, who proceeded to throw the game away.

Two-for-one special in Buffalo

In a must-win game against the rival Buffalo Bills in the 2022 regular season finale, the Patriots gave up a touchdown on the opening kickoff to returner Nyheim Hines. Good luck beating the Josh Allen-led Bills when you’re handing out freebies before the game even starts.

To add insult to injury, the Patriots gave up another touchdown on a kick return in the same game, which resulted in them losing and missing the playoffs for a second time in three seasons.

By the end of the game, Nyheim Hines should have changed his name to “Duncan” Hines because he was slipping tackles like he was “Sweetness”, the late, great Walter Payton.

The Miami Miracle

One of the most embarrassing losses in Patriots’ history is without a doubt the “Miami Miracle” in the 2018 season.

How did it even happen?

The Dolphins were completely out of it, and someway, somehow, they mustered up an impossible lateral sequence to score a game-winning touchdown.

Seeing legendary tight end Rob Gronkowski flail on a missed tackle at the end was a gut punch for a Patriots fan base wondering one thing in that fateful moment: Why was he even out there?

Benching of Malcolm Butler leads to shocking Super Bowl LII loss.

Bill Belichick benched Malcolm Butler, who was the Patriots’ starting cornerback across from Stephon Gilmore at the time, and watched his team get carved up like filet mignon by Philadelphia Eagles’ backup quarterback Nick Foles at Super Bowl LII.

The loss came in a game where Tom Brady put on a superhuman performance by throwing for 505 yards and three touchdowns against an elite Eagles defense. An argument could be made the Patriots would be seven-time Super Bowl champs if Belichick started Butler.

Destruction of the almost perfect season

Nothing cuts deeper for a Patriots’ fan than the mere mention of Super Bowl XLII.

It’s hurts so bad that it feels like it happened only yesterday. Eli Manning was seemingly given the strength of the gods in the waning moments of the fourth quarter to avoid a sack on a crucial third down, and he heaved up a prayer ball that somehow stuck to David Tyree’s helmet.

The Giants went on to punch the ball into the end zone and muster a defensive stand in a 17-14 victory.

Losing one game in an entire season isn’t nearly as bad as Brady laughing at the mention of the Giants holding the Patriots’ offense to 17 points.

The meltdown in Indy

Does anyone remember the time Peyton Manning Tom Brady’d Tom Brady?

That’s probably on the short list of things to forget during Brady’s legendary run with the Patriots. Brady and company were ahead 21-6 at halftime in the 2006 AFC Championship game against the Indianapolis Colts, before Manning stormed back out on the field and forced one of the worst playoff meltdowns ever for a Belichick-coached team.

2003 season-opening shutout loss to Buffalo

The Patriots were the reigning Super Bowl champions on the road against a Buffalo Bills team expected to get rolled on in the 2003 regular season opener.

Well, the exact opposite happened with the Patriots getting crushed like a bug on a windshield.

By the end of the game, Patriots fans were begging someone to turn on the wipers just to get the blowout over with and move on to the next week. It was a hard reality check for New England, who fell in defeat to their AFC East rivals in a surprising 31-0 loss.

Miami's wild cat spectacle

There’s a reason why the Patriots defense is so good at defending the wildcat formation. It’s because they were absolutely gashed by it in a run-in with the Miami Dolphins in 2008.

Running back Ronnie Brown did whatever he wanted to the Patriots in a game where they looked completely helpless. He ran for 113 yards and four touchdowns, while also chalking up a passing touchdown as well.

Ricky Williams also had a big game with 98 yards on 16 carries in the 38-13 victory.

The buzz saw at Arrowhead

Monday Night Football doesn’t get much uglier than this.

The Patriots got pounded like a drum at Arrowhead Stadium in a 41-14 loss back in 2014. Brady couldn’t get anything going with the offense, and the defense had an epic collapse. The Patriots were beaten and battered like they were the stars in a “Rocky” movie without the happy ending.

The Philly Special

Brady threw for 505 yards and three touchdowns against the Philadelphia Eagles at Super Bowl LII, but the only thing haters seem to remember is the legendary quarterback’s mishap when lining up at receiver on an attempted trick play.

Despite being wide open, Brady dropped a beautiful pass thrown by receiver Danny Amendola, completely nixing a play that would have put the Patriots in scoring position.

If that wasn’t bad enough, the Eagles responded with the same play to Nick Foles and connected on a touchdown later in the same quarter.

Dirty plays by Mac Jones?

Is Mac Jones a dirty player?

I’ll leave that one up for you to decide, but this compilation of “dirty plays” over the course of his NFL career didn’t help matters. Former NFL receiver Torrey Smith even went as far as comparing Jones to Milwaukee Bucks guard Grayson Allen.

Questionable or downright controversial things have a tendency to happen when Jones is on the field. He ended up being fined for a low block hit on Cincinnati Bengals cornerback Eli Apple in a 2022 regular season meeting.

More Patriots Analysis

32 NFL veterans who could lose their jobs to rookies in 2023

Patriots fans having mixed reactions to latest DeAndre Hopkins buzz

5 under-the-radar Patriots players that could break out in 2023

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Eva Mendes Opens Up About Motherhood And Family Values
Eva Mendes opens up about motherhood, career decisions, and prioritizing family over fame in a candid interview.
Top News
Top News
JJ Redick brutally roasted Shaq for not being able to dunk in high school despite being 7-feet tall
Poor Shaq wasn't always SHAQ.
USA Today Sports Media Group
USA Today Sports Media Group
Jerry Seinfeld’s Pop-Tart Movie Starts on Netflix May 3
‘Unfrosted’ is about the battle in Battle Creek, as Kellogg’s and Post fight to invent perfect breakfast treat
Broadcasting & Cable
Broadcasting & Cable
Makeup brand faces outrage over 'disrespectful' foundation shade
Another makeup brand appears to have missed the mark.
The Street
The Street
Unpacking Drew's cringe "Momala" moment
Was it the close-talking or the fact that other powerful women wouldn't have been asked to hug the nation?
Salon
Salon
“It was very emotional. He said, ‘This is where it belongs’”: Jon Bon Jovi has been reunited with the first guitar he ever owned, 45 years after he sold it
The singer wrote a song with the Univox Stratocaster copy for the band's forthcoming album, Forever
Guitar World
Guitar World
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.
Download on the AppStore Get it on Google Play