Every car guy has one that got away…. the ride he sold too soon and still dreams about. (I know I do anyway.) Whether it was traded for something “more practical” or sold during a rough patch, certain cars have only grown more desirable with time. From the Porsche 911 993 to the legendary Toyota Supra, these vehicles have skyrocketed in value and nostalgia alike. The market for classic sports cars has exploded, making some of these once-attainable machines worth small fortunes today. Here are 10 cars men regret selling the most and what they’re worth now.
1. Porsche 911 (993): The Last of the Air-Cooled Legends
The Porsche 911 993 represents the final chapter of Porsche’s air-cooled era, and that alone makes it special. Its combination of analog handling and timeless design has aged like fine wine. Many owners sold theirs before the classic car boom, only to see prices double and even triple. Clean examples of the 993 now fetch between $120,000 and $250,000, depending on the trim. This model marks a golden age of Porsche engineering that modern cars can’t quite replicate, making it one of the top cars men regret selling.
2. Alfa Romeo GTV: Italy’s Forgotten Gem
The Alfa Romeo GTV is the kind of car that made men fall in love with driving again. With its crisp lines and soulful engine, it was a pure expression of Italian passion on four wheels. Unfortunately, many were sold off before collectors realized their true potential. Today, a pristine GTV can command $60,000 to $100,000, and values keep rising as enthusiasts rediscover this vintage masterpiece. Those who let one go now find themselves chasing its unique blend of elegance and emotion.
3. Ford GT (2005–2007): America’s Supercar Comeback
When Ford reintroduced the GT in the mid-2000s, it wasn’t just nostalgia; it was a statement. The car captured the essence of the original GT40 while packing modern engineering that rivaled Ferrari. Many buyers sold theirs after a few years, never expecting values to soar. Fast forward to today, and these GTs routinely sell for $400,000 to over $600,000. It’s safe to say anyone who parted with one too soon now looks back with deep regret and an empty garage spot.
4. Mercedes-Benz Pagoda SL: A Symbol of Effortless Cool
The Pagoda SL (produced between 1963 and 1971) wasn’t just a luxury roadster. It was a lifestyle. Known for its distinctive concave roof, it became a cultural icon that symbolized sophistication and success. Many men sold theirs when newer SLs hit the market, not realizing this one would become a collectible. Restored versions now bring in $150,000 to $300,000, depending on condition. The Pagoda’s effortless cool makes it one of those cars men regret selling more than almost any other classic.
5. Toyota Supra (Mk 4): From Cult Classic to Collector Gold
The Mk 4 Toyota Supra went from street racer to collector royalty, thanks in part to The Fast and the Furious. With its 2JZ engine capable of immense tuning potential, it’s one of Japan’s greatest exports. Many owners let them go for under $30,000 years ago, never expecting what came next. Today, unmodified examples can sell for $150,000 to over $250,000. For many, this is the ultimate “why did I sell it?” regret story in automotive history.
6. Honda NSX (1st Gen): The Everyday Supercar
Honda’s first-generation NSX rewrote the supercar rulebook. It offered Ferrari-like thrills with Japanese reliability, something unheard of in the early ’90s. Owners who sold theirs for a fraction of their current value are still kicking themselves. A clean, low-mile NSX now averages $100,000 to $150,000, with special editions fetching more. Its balance, engineering precision, and timeless styling make it one of the cars men regret selling most today.
7. Mazda RX-7 (FD): The Rotary That Stole Hearts
The FD Mazda RX-7 wasn’t just fast; it was an experience. Its rotary engine, lightweight chassis, and curvy design made it one of the best-handling cars of its era. But because of high maintenance costs, many owners gave up on them early. Now, the same cars are worth $70,000 to $120,000, depending on originality. What was once considered a niche sports car has become a symbol of pure driving joy and another car men regret selling.
8. Buick GNX: The Ultimate Sleeper
The 1987 Buick GNX was a wolf in grandma’s clothing. It looked like an unassuming Regal but packed a turbocharged punch that embarrassed Corvettes of its time. With only 547 units made, rarity has sent values skyrocketing. Today, a low-mile GNX can easily surpass $200,000, and collectors are willing to pay top dollar. Many owners who sold theirs in the ’90s for a quick profit now wish they’d held on for the ride.
9. Land Rover Defender 90: The Rugged Icon
The 1997 Defender 90 represents everything people love about classic Land Rovers, including the boxy design, unstoppable off-road ability, and sheer toughness. Its short production window in the U.S. makes it particularly collectible. Many owners traded them for newer SUVs without realizing how rare they’d become. These days, clean Defenders can go for $120,000 to $200,000, especially restored versions. It’s another perfect example of how time and nostalgia have transformed utility into luxury.
10. BMW M3 (E46): The Perfect Driver’s Car
The 2002 BMW M3 (E46) hit the sweet spot of power, balance, and analog precision. Its high-revving inline-six and manual transmission made every drive memorable. Owners who sold theirs during the depreciation years now see values climbing again. Today, an E46 M3 in great condition sells for $60,000 to $100,000, and limited editions like the CSL fetch even more. This car remains one of the purest expressions of BMW’s “Ultimate Driving Machine” ethos, and one men regret selling the most.
Why These Cars Still Tug at Men’s Hearts
Cars like these aren’t just machines. They represent milestones, memories, and freedom. Selling them might have made sense at the time, but nostalgia and skyrocketing resale values have turned regret into heartbreak. The lesson? Sometimes the cars we love the most are worth more than their blue book value. If you’re lucky enough to still own one, consider it an investment in both passion and history.
Have you ever sold a car you still regret parting with? What was it, and how much would it be worth today? Share your story in the comments!
What to Read Next
- 3 Cars Experts Say Could Skyrocket in Value Soon
- Love Classic Cars? Experts Say These 8 Models Will Break Your Heart (and Wallet)
- 11 Legendary Cars Every Man Should Drive Once
- Why Do Men Choose Cars That Break Their Budgets Every Year?
- 10 Cars That Instantly Ruin a Man’s Image With Women
The post 10 Cars Men Regret Selling the Most (And What They’re Worth Now) appeared first on Clever Dude Personal Finance & Money.
