Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
The Street
The Street
Rob Lenihan

Where High Mortgage Rates Cost Homebuyers the Most

The word “mortgage” can trace its roots back to a medieval legal term meaning “death pledge.”

Things are not so dramatic today, but for most people, buying a house is the biggest expenditure of their lives. And lately it’s just getting more expensive.

DON'T MISS: 10 Cities Where Middle-Income Buyers Can Find Affordable Homes

In fact, a buyer on a $3,000 monthly housing budget has lost $30,000 in purchasing power over the last five months, in part due to mortgage rate increases, according to the real estate platform Redfin.

As of July 20, the 30-year fixed mortgage rate was 6.78%, up 1.24% from a year ago. The 15-year fixed mortgage rate was 6.06%, up 1.31% from a year ago.

One to two percent may seem like a small increase, but the effect on a monthly mortgage payment can be drastic -- especially when coupled with a surge in home prices.

“Prices are rising despite relatively low demand because there are so few homes for sale,” Redfin said in its housing market update. “New listings are down 27% year-over-year, the biggest drop since the start of the pandemic, and the total number of homes on the market is down 14%, the biggest drop since March 2022."

“That’s mostly because potential sellers are locked in by low rates; nearly all homeowners have a rate below 6%," Redfin reported.

The economy has an impact on mortgage rates, as they tend to rise when things are going well and fall when there’s a slowdown.

Mortgage Bankers Association (MBA) vice president and deputy chief economist Joel Kan expects mortgage rates to average 5.6% by the end of 2023, Forbes reported, while Realtor.com economist Jiayi Xu expects a gradual decline that could bring rates near 6% by year-end.

Compare the Best Loan Rates

Skyrocketing Mortgage Payments

Broadly speaking, homeownership got more expensive over the last year for new buyers. In some housing markets the cost difference is stark, Q1 data from the National Association of Realtors reveals.

In 20 U.S. counties, the median mortgage payment rose at least $1,610 year-over-year, according to the data. In one pricey New York market, the typical monthly payment jumped more than $3,000. 

Source: National Association of Realtors

To calculate these figures, NAR assumed a 10% down payment on a 30-year fixed loan, the most common type of mortgage (repeat homebuyers and first-time buyers, respectively, put down a median of 17% and 6%). 

A homebuyers’ income, credit history, and other personal factors impact their individual mortgage rate and ultimately how much they pay each month. 

The following table shows the counties where the monthly cost of a mortgage  increased the most over the last year. Payments exclude additional monthly expenses like insurance and taxes.

The National Association of Realtors, County Median Home Prices and Monthly Mortgage Payment

County, State Median Home Price, Q1 2023 Monthly Payment Q1 2023 Cost Difference From a Year Ago

Nantucket County, MA

$1,444,050

$7,480

+ $3,440

San Mateo County, CA

$1,575,280 

$8,160

+ $2,890

Santa Clara County, CA

$1,459,600 

$7,560

+ $2,820

Dukes County, MA

$1,143,610 

$5,920

+ $2,720

Marin County, CA

$1,467,100 

$7,600

+ $2,700

San Francisco County, CA

$1,458,510 

$7,550

+ $2,680

Teton County, ID

$1,102,970 

$5,710

+ $2,180

Honolulu County, HI

$965,000 

$5,000

+ $2,080

Alameda County, CA

$1,072,780 

$5,550

+ $1,960

New York County, NY

$1,042,100 

$5,400

+ $1,890

Maui County, HI

$898,020 

$4,650

+ $1,870

Santa Cruz County, CA

$1,020,890 

$5,290

+ $1,850

Orange County, CA

$956,470 

$4,950

+ $1,840

Pitkin County, CO

$875,480 

$4,530

+ $1,800

Monroe County, FL

$816,090 

$4,230

+ $1,760

Williamson County, TN

$774,160 

$4,010

+ $1,710

San Diego County, CA

$843,960 

$4,370

+ $1,680

Summit County, UT

$850,430 

$4,400

+ $1,660

Falls Church city, VA

$921,730 

$4,770

+ $1,640

King County, WA

$851,460 

$4,410

+ $1,610

Nantucket, a small island off Cape Cod, Mass. and a top summer destination, saw the biggest jump in monthly payments among all U.S. counties.

California had three of the most expensive markets in the top five counties. San Mateo, one of the wealthiest counties in the U.S., saw the second-highest monthly payment increase. Many residents are associated with bioscience and computer software, which may explain why it is such an expensive place to live.

Housing Markets With Less Mortgage Rate Impact

Rising rates didn't have as much of an impact on buyers in relatively cheaper housing markets.

In Youngstown, Ohio, which has the highest share of affordable homes on the market for middle-income buyers, monthly home payments increased a mere $300 from a year ago. In Akron, Ohio, another affordable metro area, monthly payments increased just $380 from a year ago.

The Takeaway: California housing markets have recorded some of the biggest increases in mortgage payments over the last year, pushing the median monthly payment as high as $8,000 in one county.

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.