The NFL Players Association (NFLPA) is once again at odds with the Competition Committee over a proposed ban on 'swivel hip-drop' tackles. The proposal, which aims to prohibit a controversial tackling technique where a defender wraps the ball carrier and drops their hips, is set to be voted on by all 32 NFL teams at the upcoming annual spring meetings in Orlando, Florida.
This particular tackle has sparked debate within the league due to the injuries it has caused to several players. NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell has been a vocal advocate for the rule change in an effort to enhance player safety.
In response to the proposal, the NFLPA released a statement expressing their opposition to the ban on 'swivel hip-drop' tackles. While emphasizing their commitment to improving the game with health and safety in mind, the NFLPA raised concerns about potential confusion for players, coaches, officials, and fans if the rule were to be implemented.
One notable incident cited in the discussion is former San Francisco 49ers safety Jimmie Ward's tackle on Dallas Cowboys running back Tony Pollard during the 2022 postseason, which resulted in a significant ankle injury for Pollard.
According to data from Pro Football Talk, a review of 20,000 tackles since 2022 identified 105 instances of 'swivel hip-drop' tackles, with a significantly higher risk of injury compared to standard tackles.
Despite the push for the ban, the challenge lies in identifying such tackles in real-time, as acknowledged by NFL executive vice president of football operations, Troy Vincent. The complexity of distinguishing between a 'swivel hip-drop' tackle and a regular tackle poses a significant hurdle for officials.
Players argue that prioritizing safety and proper technique while in the heat of competition can be challenging, as their focus is primarily on helping their team win games.
The fate of the proposed ban now rests with the NFL teams, as a minimum of 24 teams must vote in favor of its enforcement for the upcoming season. If approved, a 15-yard penalty will be imposed on the field for any 'swivel hip-drop' tackles.
