Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
ABC News
ABC News
Sport

Australia set for another spin Test against India as Border-Gavaskar Trophy heads to fortress Delhi

Last time Virat Kohli played in a Test match at the venue he scored 243 and 50. (Getty Images: Pankaj Nangia/The India Today Group)

After a humbling defeat in Nagpur and questions flying left, right and centre about team selection, Australia's tour of India moves to the capital Delhi, where the tourists face another daunting prospect at one of India's most dominant Test venues. 

Australia's innings and 132-run defeat in the first Test, where spin played such a huge role in bowling Australia out for its lowest ever total against India in India, will give the hosts confidence that they can just repeat the formula throughout the tour.

That and the fact that Australia has never won a four-Test series having gone behind 1-0.

Australia has called up spin reinforcements of its own in the form of Queensland left arm spinner Matthew Kuhnemann, but the real question will be whether Australia's batters can turn around their form to rise to the challenge posed by Ravichanrdan Ashwin, Ravindra Jadeja and Axar Patel.

Those Indian spinners took 16 of India's 20 wickets in the first Test — and it would surprise nobody if that pattern was repeated in Delhi.

Listen to full commentary of the second Test between India and Australia on ABC Sport or follow in our live blog.

Fortress Delhi

India's Test cricket fortress, the Arun Jaitley Stadium at the Feroz Shah Kotla ground in Delhi. (Getty Images: Michael Steele)

The Feroz Shah Kotla ground — now known as the Arun Jaitley Stadium — is India's second-oldest cricket ground and was named after the nearby 14th century fort built by the Sultanate of Delhi.

That the ground is named after a fortress is apt, given India's record at the venue in Test matches.

It's been a little over 35 years since India has tasted defeat at the Feroz Shah Kotla ground — making it one of India's most formidable Test venues.

It has to be said, India has only played 12 Tests there in that time, the most recent coming in December 2017 — a high-scoring draw with Sri Lanka that was plagued by reports of smog that led to complaints from Sri Lankan players.

Conditions in Delhi were dire the last time a Test was played in the city. (Getty Images: Pankaj Nangia/The India Today Group)

As ABC Sport commentator Corbin Middlemas noted on his arrival in the capital last week, the smog could play a role in this Test too — although fortunately air quality appears to have improved in the past couple of days.

All up, India has been beaten just six times in 34 Tests played at the venue — but all six of those defeats came between 1959 and 1987 — ancient history as far as modern cricket goes.

Australia were the first overseas team to win a Test in Delhi back in 1959. when Richie Benaud took match figures of 8-76 off just shy of 50 overs and Neil Harvey made 114 with the bat.

Since then, Australia has lost three and drawn three — most recently losing by six wickets in 2013, when Jadeja took match figures of 7-98 and the only Australian to pass 50 with the bat was, incredibly, Peter Siddle — twice.

Nathan Lyon took 7-94 in the first innings of that match as 29 of the 34 wickets to fall went to the spinners.

Things haven't been all good for India in Delhi though.

In ODI cricket, India has won just one of its past three matches and has just one win in three T20Is at the venue as well.

In 2009, an ODI match with Sri Lanka at the venue was abandoned due to an unsafe pitch, which saw the venue banned from hosting international cricket for 12 months. 

Sri Lanka were also the team that complained about the air quality in 2017.

The ground has also had its run ins with wildlife, with the 2008 Test against Australia marked by an extraordinary moment on day three when a swarm of bees forced everyone in the middle to dive to the ground.

Bees stopped play when Australia visited in 2008 for a high-scoring draw. (Getty Images: Michael Steele)

India's impressive record in Delhi has drawn optimistic comparisons to Australia's own Test fortress the Gabba, which was, until 2021, just as impregnable to opposition teams.

Australia were unbeaten for just over 32 years in Brisbane, a run of 31 Tests since the West Indies won in 1988 (using largely the same team that beat India in Delhi the year before, by the way) until India broke that drought so spectacularly in 2021.

The comparison to that Gabba record may just be an attempt to tempt fate — but there are other comparisons.

India were humiliated in Adelaide in the first Test of that series, getting bowled out for just 36 as Australia won by eight wickets.

Despite that humiliation, India did not lose another Test and won the series 2-1 with that drought-ending victory in Brisbane.

Food for thought, perhaps.

Will Australia make changes?

Travis Head's omission from the first Test team left plenty of people scratching theirs. (Getty Images: Robert Cianflone)

The elephant in the selection room for the last Test was the omission of Travis Head, with the South Australian's struggles against spin in the subcontinent counting against him despite his career-best form during the Australian summer rocketing him up to fourth in the ICC Test batter rankings.

Head's selection may well depend on other personnel being available though, with Cameron Green the key to creating balance in the side.

Indications suggest Green will miss out in Delhi, but Mitch Starc is raring to go after his own finger injury and could replace Scott Boland, despite the Victorian paceman impressing with his economy in Nagpur and largely out-performing his skipper. 

Todd Murphy will have done enough with his seven wickets on debut to retain his place and will almost certainly partner Nathan Lyon.

In Nagpur, a big fuss was made of how India prepared the pitch for the left arm spinners to execute best to Australia's left-handed batters.

Does that mean Australia needs a left arm spinner in their side?

"I think consistently we've seen over there [in India] the power of having a left-arm finger spinner," Ed Cowan told the Grandstand Cricket Podcast.

"[If] I was an Australian selector … I'd get [Matthew] Kuhnemann on a plane pretty quick smart.

"I think they need a left-arm finger spinner and sure, [Ashton] Agar has been picked on the tour but I'm not sure he's the one to do the job for the team."

Kuhnemann was dispatched to India shortly after taking 2-55 and 1-67 at the MCG — just seven of 40 wickets fell to spin on a pace-friendly wicket —as Queensland were beaten by 164 runs by Victoria.

Kuhnemann's Queensland teammate Mitch Swepson is the other spinner already in India but Cowan was not convinced that leg spin is the way to go in India.

Why did Murphy out-bowl Lyon in Nagpur?

Todd Murphy was far more effective than Nathan Lyon in Nagpur. (Getty Images: Robert Cianflone)

The only highlight from Nagpur was the way Todd Murphy took to Test cricket.

His were the sixth-best innings figures by an Australian on debut — yet, incredibly, just the second-best by an Australian spinner on debut in Nagpur behind Jason Krejza's 8-215 in 2008.

Lyon is, of course, an off spinner like Murphy, but they do bowl differently.

"Lyon [bowls] up and over [while] Todd Murphy [bowls] quicker, flatter into the pitch," Cowan said.

"We know Nathan Lyon relies on bounce, but because of the overspin he puts on the ball, we've seen Murphy almost bowl what cricketers would call more square deliveries; they're not over the top, more of an angled wrist, skidding on, but almost Ashwin-like.

"They are different off-spinners and you can see them working together in the same team, but Murphy's style of bowling is far more effective in those conditions."

That is also why finger spin tends to be more effective than wrist spin in India.

"We've seen time and time again on the low, slow, Indian turning wickets, you need to bowl into the wicket and the nature of leg-spin is you have to bowl over the wrist so the ball comes up out of the hand before it goes down," Cowan explained.

"The air goes out of the ball and out of the wicket and it can be very ineffective.

"We've seen the greatest leg-spinner of all time, Shane Warne, struggle in those conditions, and we've seen people who can bowl like Ashton Agar, which is fast and into the wicket, but with far greater control, really cause havoc."

That is born out in the stats.

Shane Warne was least effective in India than anywhere else in his career and by quite a distance.

The leg-spin great took 34 wickets at 43.11 in India, compared to a career average of 25.41.

Will this pitch spin?

Historically, Delhi has been a turning wicket.

Todd Murphy took his first five-wicket haul in a first class match in his first Test. (Getty Images: Robert Cianflone)

In the last four Tests played at the ground, spinners have taken 87 wickets compared to 43 taken by seam-up bowlers.

The last time Australia played in Delhi, only five of the 34 wickets fell to pace bowlers, with Ashwin and Jadeja taking seven each for the match and Lyon taking nine on his own.

That is the biggest discrepancy between pace and spin of any of the last four Tests played at the venue.

The split between left- and right-arm spinners, by the way, is just over 60:40 in favour of right-arm off spinners, with leg spin taking just 10 wickets — adding some credence to Cowan's suggestion that Swepson might not be the best option.

Both India's premier off spinners do enjoy bowling in Delhi, though.

Ravindra Jadeja has an astonishing record in Test matches in Delhi. (Getty Images: Pankaj Nangia/The India Today Group)

Ashwin took 7-112 when Australia last played there and Jadeja 7-98 — and those figures are illustrative of how both men have thrived in the Tests they've played in Delhi.

Ashwin has 27 wickets at an average of 21.11 in four Tests at the Arun Jaitley Stadium, with three five-wicket hauls. 

Jadeja has 19 at an incredible average of 16.89 from his three Tests at the venue.

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.