Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
The Guardian - UK
The Guardian - UK
Comment
Observer editorial

After Iran’s attack on Israel, further escalation must be stopped

Demonstrators wave Iran's flag and Palestinian flags as they gather at Palestine Square in Tehran
Demonstrators wave Iran's flag and Palestinian flags as they gather at Palestine Square in Tehran on 14 April. Photograph: Atta Kenare/AFP/Getty Images

Iran’s airborne military attack on Israel, launched on Saturday night, has the potential to turn the crisis in Gaza into a full-scale Middle East war, drawing in the US and other countries including Britain. This is the scenario that western and Arab governments have been dreading ever since the 7 October attacks on Israel by Hamas, Iran’s close ally. Now that the worst has come to pass, no one can know where or how it will end. This unprecedented head-to-head confrontation between Israel and Iran must be defused before it spins completely out of control.

First reports from Israel, quoting the Israel Defense Forces (IDF), said Iran had launched dozens of drones at presumed Israeli targets. Then came news, impossible to verify, that Iran was also firing cruise missiles – a far greater and swifter menace. Israel said its air defence and anti-missile systems were on full alert and that Israeli air space was being shut down. Jordan and Iraq announced similar measures. Saudi reports said the US had intercepted some of the drones over Syria and Iraq. Hezbollah in Lebanon and Houthi forces in Yemen also fired missiles at Israel in what looked like a concerted offensive.

“A short time ago, Iran launched unmanned aerial vehicles from its territory towards the territory of the state of Israel … the IDF aerial defence array is on high alert, along with Israel air force fighter jets and Israeli navy vessels that are on a defence mission in Israeli airspace. The IDF is monitoring all targets,” an Israeli army spokesperson said. The White House confirmed that an Iranian airborne attack had begun, and said President Joe Biden was being updated by his national security advisers.

It must be assumed that if the Iranian drones and missiles hit targets on Israeli territory or hit Israeli cities, the government of Benjamin Netanyahu will respond in kind, as it has threatened to do. Last week Biden indicated that the US would support and possibly join any retaliatory Israeli military action. Israel, he said, had America’s “iron-clad” backing. In such a situation, the pressure on America’s and Israel’s allies to assist in any subsequent clashes will be considerable. Rishi Sunak must think very carefully about what he does next.

What is needed now above all are cool heads. Netanyahu and his extremist coalition allies are not renowned for such qualities. That makes it all the more important that the Americans, and Britain, use all their persuasive powers and all available diplomatic means to try to moderate Israel’s reaction and stop further attacks by Iran. Netanyahu’s first instinct, if Israel is badly hit, may be to attack Iran’s nuclear facilities, which he has threatened to do in the past, and possibly, regime leadership targets in Tehran, too. To do so that would be to risk another twist in the spiral of escalation, leading inexorably to all-out war.

It is vital that this conflagration be extinguished with the utmost speed for, if not, it may quickly spread across the region, igniting the already smouldering Occupied West Bank and beyond. Such a calamity would prolong Gaza’s misery, wreck hostage talks and extend instability into Lebanon and maybe Iraq, Syria, the Gulf and the Red Sea, too.

An open-ended US-Iran confrontation would divide the western democracies, chill the global economy, destabilise pro-western Arab states, boost China’s geopolitical ambitions and sideline the fight against intensifying Russian aggression in Ukraine. More than that, it would be a gift to Netanyahu and his far-right allies, whose only policy is perpetual war.

Amid the present tumult, it should not be forgotten that this Iranian attack was provoked, according to Iran’s leadership at least, by Israel’s unacknowledged bombing on 1 April of an Iranian embassy annex in Damascus that killed several senior commanders. In Tehran’s not unreasonable view, that attack crossed a red line by targeting diplomatic premises. For the Supreme Leader, Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, it amounted to an assault on sovereign Iranian territory. It could not go unanswered.

A complex spider’s web of calculation, ambiguity and hidden motives lies behind last night’s confrontation. Iran has sought to capitalise on the Gaza war, expanding its regional influence through proxy forces in Syria, Iraq, Yemen and Lebanon – the “axis of resistance”. While denying advance knowledge of the 7 October attacks, it has maintained support for Hamas and applauded Hezbollah’s ensuing bombardment of northern Israel. But it had avoided, until now, direct confrontation with Israel.

Its decision to attack, ultimately ignoring the pleadings of European and Arab foreign ministers and a direct intervention by David Cameron, the foreign secretary, reflects the dominance in Tehran of the hardliners who hold the levers of power. Their ideological hatred of Israel and the US is visceral.

For them, confrontation with the west is the ultimate, perhaps only justification for the terrible sacrifices and disastrous policies the Islamic theocracy, founded after the 1979 revolution, has foisted on the Iranian people.

A not totally dissimilar dynamic is evident inside Israel, where Netanyahu’s extreme rightwing coalition is up against a wall. Its shameful conduct of the Gaza war has heaped international opprobrium on Israel’s head while failing to defeat Hamas. Opponents say Netanyahu is prolonging – and expanding – the war to save his skin.

On this reading, the Damascus embassy attack was a deliberate escalation designed to fortify his political position, flush out Iran and draw the blind-sided Americans back to his side.

Do you have an opinion on the issues raised in this article? If you would like to submit a letter of up to 250 words to be considered for publication, email it to us at observer.letters@observer.co.uk

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.